SELIS V2 / alternative-directions

Alternative directions — overview

15 November 2026. Requested by Ivaylo in chat: five to seven ideas for lunar software products that serve private and public customers other than ESA, worldwide, linked to CLPS, the lunar economy and ESA and JAXA lunar plans. Each idea must be able to start as a Type A activity.

Status: input for the grilling session (grilling-brief.md). Nothing here is a decision, and CLAUDE.md and decisions-log.md are unchanged.

Compiled with AI (Claude); not re-checked by a person. No organisation was contacted. Web sources were opened on 15 November 2026, most of them as search extracts or automated page summaries (marked in section 8). Re-open each source before a sentence built on it enters the proposal. "Judgement" marks an assessment, not a sourced fact. "Not found" means searched and not found. A, A2, A3, B, C and F refer to the files in research/findings/ (F exists only as render/research-html/F-geotechnical-alternative.html).

Abbreviations not in glossary.md: CLPS = Commercial Lunar Payload Services (NASA); PRISM = Payloads and Research Investigations on the Surface of the Moon (NASA); SSF = Space Strategy Fund (Japan, run by JAXA); ATLAC = Action Team on Lunar Activities Consultation (United Nations); PSR = permanently shadowed region; PSI = plume-surface interaction; LoS = line of sight; DTE = direct to Earth; RHU = radioisotope heater unit; CF = critical function.

1. How the ideas were chosen

2. New facts since findings A to C

  1. NASA selected eight companies for CLPS 2 on 7 November 2026: Blue Origin, Firefly Aerospace, Intuitive Machines, ispace-U.S., Lockheed Martin Space, Northrop Grumman Space Systems, SpaceX and Voyager Technologies. The contract runs 10 years with a ceiling of USD 10 billion. NASA raised the first CLPS contract from USD 2.6 billion to USD 4.2 billion [1].
  2. The same release names a nuclear-powered South Pole rover (PROMISE, launch target late 2028, 18 months, drill to about 1 m), component awards for a solar and communications tower (miniCAST: Honeybee Robotics, Redwire, Yank Technologies), a solicitation for integrated power systems expected in early 2027, and a planned call that may buy data from commercial partners to close Moon Base data gaps [1].
  3. NASA selected three PRISM payload suites on 30 September 2026: a South Pole environment monitoring station, a geophysical survey of the Marius Hills pit (GIMLI), and an imager for ice in micro cold traps that also studies how rocket exhaust disturbs the ground (DISCO). No lander or date is named [2].
  4. NASA's VIPER rover is planned to launch in August 2027 and land in September 2027 on Blue Origin's Blue Moon MK1 [3].
  5. Japan funds lunar work through the SSF: prospecting instruments and a resource exploration method (University of Tokyo and partners), and surveying, geotechnical investigation, a data platform and civil design methods for lunar bases (Ritsumeikan University), both running to about 2030 or 2031 [7]. ispace received a grant of JPY 11.6 billion for landing within ±100 m near the South Pole, with a Mission 4 launch in 2029 [8].
  6. The United Nations action team ATLAC is working on a possible international mechanism for information sharing and consultation on lunar activities; a commentary expects its final report in 2027 [16][17].

Effect (judgement): the number of landers, rovers, power assets and payload teams that need site analysis grows on the United States and Japanese side, not only on the ESA side described in C.

3. The six ideas

"First users" are candidates. None was contacted. "D17" is the fixed direction: mission-planning software with a South Pole focus.

# Working name Product in one line First users outside ESA (candidates) Inside D17 File
1 Thermal environment for surface assets Time series of heat fluxes and sink temperature for an asset at a site, with stated uncertainty, through day, night and shadow Lander, rover and payload teams under CLPS and PRISM; night-survival hardware makers; Japanese rover and thermal-device developers Yes 01-thermal-environment-for-surface-assets.md
2 Volatile prospecting planner Ice prospectivity with uncertainty, and a ranking of measurement stops by expected information gain Prospecting rover teams (ispace, Space Applications Services, Japanese SSF consortia), resource companies Yes 02-volatile-prospecting-planner.md
3 Surface activity interference assessment Zones of effect of a planned landing or operation on neighbouring assets, and a notification data set Lander operators, national authorities, registry operators such as Open Lunar Foundation Yes 03-surface-activity-interference-assessment.md
4 Power network layout planner Layout of generation, storage and distribution for several assets, with delivered-power availability per consumer Lunar power developers (the Lithuanian lead, Maana Electric, Voyager, Honda, Volta), mast and array makers Yes 04-power-network-layout-planner.md
5 Pit and lava-tube access planner Geometry, light, temperature and access analysis for one lunar pit GIMLI and LunarLeaper teams, Japanese lava-tube research groups [TBD from Martin's CV] No: not at the South Pole 05-pit-and-lava-tube-access-planner.md
6 Communications and navigation availability planner Link and positioning availability at a site across several relay providers and DTE, with terrain masking Payload and rover teams choosing a relay service; relay operators Yes 06-communications-and-navigation-availability-planner.md

Reference point: the working candidate from A3, power siting with a stated confidence for one asset. Idea 4 extends it; ideas 1 and 3 can share its terrain ensemble and its validation data.

4. Scores against the four tests

All verdicts are judgements. Reasons and sources are in each idea file.

# Unique Feasible Needed Fits Type A Team fit shown in the CVs on file
1 Thermal environment Pass: no European supplier found; NASA does it in-house Pass in sunlit terrain; weak inside PSRs Pass Pass Not shown
2 Prospecting planner Pass with thin evidence: one United States model exists; Europe not searched in depth Weak: almost no in-situ data before VIPER Pass Weak: checks rest mainly on other model products Not shown
3 Interference assessment Pass: registries exist, an analysis tool was not found Weak: far-field ejecta has no measured data Weak: policy need shown, paying user not shown Pass Partly: a data service suits the cloud background; plume physics not shown
4 Power network layout Weak: research studies exist; a multi-asset tool with uncertainty was not found Pass Pass Pass Closest to the work done so far
5 Pit access planner Pass: no planning tool found (one search) Weak: the interior is unobserved Weak: few missions, late dates Pass, but outside the South Pole focus Possible through Martin [TBD]
6 Comms and navigation Weak: SSTL, NASA and ESA tools exist Pass for geometry; weak for radio propagation Pass Weak: risk of duplicating ESA Moonlight work Not shown

5. Recommendation (judgement)

  1. Lead candidates: idea 4 and idea 1. Both use the LOLA terrain ensemble and the validation recipe already described in A3 and B. Both serve power developers and lander and rover teams, which C names as the most credible first users. Pick one as the Type A core and keep the other as an option; together they exceed four critical functions.
  2. Most distinctive: idea 3. No reviewed tool computes effects between neighbouring assets. The weakness is that no source shows who pays. It can enter a proposal as one optional function of idea 4 ("effects of and on neighbours"), which limits the risk.
  3. Idea 2 has the largest set of named missions. Its verification before VIPER data is thin. It becomes stronger for a later activity, once VIPER data is public.
  4. Idea 5 depends on two things: Martin's CV must show the lava-tube work, and decision D12 (South Pole) would have to be reopened.
  5. Idea 6 should not lead. Its geometric core can be a derived layer inside ideas 1, 3 or 4.

6. Set aside, with the reason

Idea Reason
Rover route optimisation ESA funds a prototype at Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory (A2 finding 3). NASA runs Monte Carlo traverse planning for VIPER [3]. A university toolbox plans paths under time-varying light and communication windows with data uncertainty [27].
Terrain generation, hazard maps, synthetic images, XR A section 3, duplication check.
Plume physics simulation ESA activity LUNAR ISLANDS (F section 2). Idea 3 uses published results; it does not simulate plumes.
Construction-process twin and earthworks planner F section 3.2 scores it weak or fail. New fact: Japan funds surveying, geotechnical methods and civil design methods for lunar bases at Ritsumeikan University until 2031 [7]. That consortium is a possible user of site data, to be checked through Martin's contacts [TBD].
Benchmark of predictions against landed missions Useful as a verification method for ideas 1, 3 and 4 (Chandrayaan-3, Blue Ghost and Chang'e sites). It is a data set, not a product (judgement).
Radiation dose planner Not researched. No radiation expertise in the CVs on file.

7. Open points

8. Sources

Accessed 15 November 2026. "(page summary)" = read through an automated summary of the page; "(extract)" = read as a search extract; "(abstract)" = abstract or record page only; "news" = no primary source found in this chat.

  1. NASA, release 26-095, Moon Base transportation, technology and science awards, 7 November 2026 (page summary): https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-awards-moon-base-transportation-technology-science-projects/
  2. NASA, release 26-080, new science investigations for Moon Base, 30 September 2026 (page summary, read at https://www.nasa.gov/?p=1052091): https://nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-adds-new-science-investigations-for-moon-base
  3. NASA, VIPER presentation, 29 April 2026 (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260002876/downloads/viper-2026-04-29_v2.pdf
  4. Coyan et al. 2025, Planetary Science Journal 6, 105 (abstract): https://doi.org/10.3847/PSJ/adbc6c ; record: https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/70266320
  5. JAXA, cooperation with NASA on LUPEX, 24 March 2026 (extract): https://humans-in-space.jaxa.jp/en/biz-lab/news/detail/005577.html
  6. JAXA, LUPEX leaflet (extract): https://www.exploration.jaxa.jp/assets/img/program/Leaflet_LUPEX-e_A4.pdf
  7. JAXA, Space Strategy Fund, second phase, project sheets, July 2026 (page summary of the first 100,000 of 113,206 characters): https://fund.jaxa.jp/content/uploads/2nd_term_PR_sheets_EN.pdf
  8. ispace, press release, 7 August 2026 (extract): https://d2xlcgjnpyakn4.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/20260807-SSF-HPL-Grant.pdf ; ispace, disclosure notice of the same date, source of the ±100 m figure (extract): https://d2xlcgjnpyakn4.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Update-on-Previously-Disclosed-MatterNotice-Regarding-Grant-Award-Decision-for-the-Second-Phase-of-the-Space-Strategy-Fund-1.pdf
  9. Grier, Erickson and Birmingham (NASA), lunar thermal environments and sink temperature, TFAWS 2025 (abstract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250007283
  10. Birmingham et al. (NASA), meshed lunar terrain thermal model short course, TFAWS 2026 (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260007830/downloads/Meshed%20Lunar%20Terrain%20Thermal%20Model%20Short%20Course.pdf
  11. NASA, CLPS Survive the Night, January 2023 (extract): https://smd-cms.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/techshow-jej.pdf
  12. World Nuclear News, Zeno Power payload on a Firefly Blue Ghost mission, 2026, news (extract): https://world-nuclear-news.org/articles/blue-ghost-to-carry-nuclear-power-source-to-the-moon?cid=116396
  13. Hayne et al. 2017, global regolith thermophysical properties from Diviner (extract): https://arxiv.org/pdf/1711.00977
  14. Volkhardt, Bürger and Blum, EPSC-DPS 2025 abstract 660 (extract): https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC-DPS2025/EPSC-DPS2025-660.html
  15. News release on Durga Prasad et al., ChaSTE temperatures on Chandrayaan-3, 6 March 2025 (extract): https://www.eurekalert.org/news-releases/1075734
  16. UNOOSA, ATLAC page (extract): https://www.unoosa.org/unoosa/en/ourwork/copuos/atlac/index.html ; co-chairs' paper A/AC.105/2026/CRP.39, 16 June 2026 (extract only; the file did not open): https://www.unoosa.org/documents/pdf/copuos/ATLAC/AC105_2026_CRP39E.pdf
  17. The Space Review, commentary on ATLAC, August 2026 (extract): https://www.thespacereview.com/article/5285/1
  18. Open Lunar Foundation, The Lunar Ledger, conference room paper A/AC.105/2025/CRP.15 (extract): https://www.unoosa.org/res/oosadoc/data/documents/2025/aac_1052025crp/aac_1052025crp_15_0_html/AC105_2025_CRP15E.pdf
  19. Open Lunar Foundation, "Falling Falcons", 4 August 2026 (page summary): https://www.openlunar.org/blog/falling-falcons-coordination-contamination-and-the-case-for-a-public-record
  20. Clegg et al. 2014, Icarus, effects of rocket exhaust on lunar soil reflectance (abstract): https://manuscript.isc.ac/Inventory/10/2380165.htm ; Clegg-Watkins et al. 2016, Chang'e-3 landing site (abstract): https://profiles.wustl.edu/en/publications/photometric-characterization-of-the-change-3-landing-site-using-l/
  21. Tyrrell et al. (NASA), SCALPSS 1.1 post-landing terrain measurements, AIAA SciTech 2026 (abstract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250010922
  22. Korzun (NASA Langley), plume-surface interaction testing, 13 July 2026 (extract): https://nescacademy.nasa.gov/downloadFile/1546
  23. NASA, Lunar Communications Relay and Navigation Systems paper, 2026 (extract): https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/lcrns-esper-257-1.pdf
  24. NASA, LunaNet page (extract): https://www.nasa.gov/communicating-with-missions/lunanet/
  25. ADS Group, SSTL Lunar Mission Builder App, 1 September 2021, news (extract): https://www.adsgroup.org.uk/knowledge/industry-member-news/sstl-launches-lunar-mission-builder-app/
  26. Law, Gallegos and Malhotra (JPL), Line of Sight Analysis, EPSC 2021 (abstract): https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2021/EPSC2021-150.html
  27. Spencer et al. 2026, path planning in dynamic spatio-temporal space, IEEE Aerospace Conference (abstract): https://digitalcommons.mtu.edu/michigantech-p2/2760
  28. ESA, Moonlight and Lunar Pathfinder slides, June 2024 (extract): https://www.unoosa.org/documents/pdf/icg/2024/WG-B_Lunar_PNT_Jun24/LunarPNT_Jun24_01_04.pdf
  29. Payload, lunar power start-ups, 2025, news (extract): https://payloadspace.com/startups-tap-sun-nukes-to-keep-lunar-rovers-kicking
  30. SpaceNews, Volta LightGrid, news (extract): https://spacenews.com/?p=506882 ; Aerospace America (extract): https://aerospaceamerica.aiaa.org/departments/beating-the-fear-of-darkness/
  31. Preprint on orbital laser power beaming to the lunar surface, 2025 (extract): https://arxiv.org/pdf/2508.10855v2
  32. NASA Glenn, BEACON power beaming and relay tower study (extract; also C source 13): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240014584/downloads/BEACON%20Final.pdf
  33. Carrer et al. 2024, Nature Astronomy 8, 1119 (abstract): https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2024NatAs...8.1119C
  34. NASA, lunar pits and stable temperatures, 26 July 2022 (extract): https://www.nasa.gov/?p=140955
  35. Astronomy, GIMLI selection, 9 October 2026, news (extract): https://www.astronomy.com/science/newly-selected-nasa-mission-will-hunt-for-caves-on-the-moon/
  36. LunarLeaper mission concept, ETH Zurich record (extract): https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/entities/publication/273d39d5-162c-418e-96b5-24019d1472fb
  37. NASA, VIPER lunar operations page (extract): https://science.nasa.gov/mission/viper/lunar-operations/
  38. Martinez 2026, doctoral dissertation, Southern Methodist University, regolith properties under cryogenic conditions (abstract): https://scholar.smu.edu/hum_sci_earthsciences_etds/41/
  39. ispace, press release, 6 October 2025 (extract): https://ispace-inc.com/news-en/?p=8038
  40. Eos, temperatures in lunar pits, 2022 (extract): https://eos.org/articles/caves-offer-temperate-hope-for-future-moon-exploration

Internal: research/findings/A-competitors.md, A2-competitors.md, A3-uncertainty-in-planning.md, B-data-sets.md, C-users-and-needs.md; render/research-html/F-geotechnical-alternative.html; type-a-activities.md; grilling-brief.md; decisions-log.md.