SELIS V2 / research / findings

Topic C — Users and their needs: findings

13 November 2026; all sources opened that day. Bracketed numbers refer to section 8. "Judgement" marks an assessment, not a sourced fact. "(extract)" in section 8 marks a source read as a search extract of the page, not the full page. "Not found" means searched and not found. Compiled with AI (Claude); sources not yet re-checked by a person. No organisation was contacted. Corrected on 15 November 2026 from B2-site-data-coverage.md, with AI (Claude); the correction is not yet re-checked by a person.

Length: about 2,200 words before the source list. This is over the two-page limit of research-brief.md; the seven-column table accounts for the excess.

Abbreviations not in glossary.md: RSMA = Robotic Surface Mobility Asset; MRP = Moon Robotic Payload; PKT = Procellarum KREEP Terrane; PSR = permanently shadowed region; LTV = lunar terrain vehicle; A = research/findings/A-competitors.md; B = research/findings/B-data-sets.md (saved while this chat ran; read before this file was finalised).

1. Feeds

1.0 Introduction and Scope; 1.2 Requirements (end-customer justification); 1.6.1 programmatic compliance (link to ESA programmes); 1.6.2 Business Case Summary.

2. Key findings

  1. Answer. Most credible first users (judgement): (a) developers of lunar surface power, including the Lithuanian lead [TBD]; (b) European rover mission teams (ispace-Europe, Space Applications Services); (c) the Argonaut Mission 1 payload teams; (d) research groups in polar robotics and lunar power systems. Missions served: Argonaut Mission 1, MAGPIE, LUVMI-M. Strongest need: site-specific illumination and darkness time series for power sizing and surface-operations planning.
  2. Power developers already run their own site illumination studies. Honda and Astrobotic agreed in September 2025 to simulate one-year illumination profiles at several South Pole sites, to size 10 kW and 50 kW solar arrays and their energy storage [10]. A 2023 journal study found photovoltaic and battery mass of about 150,000 kg to 350,000 kg, depending on the illumination profile of the South Pole site (10 m towers, one year) [12]. A NASA Glenn design needs a tower above 10 m to keep the longest winter shadow under 100 hours [13].
  3. ESA has two South Pole surface missions that need site analyses. Argonaut Mission 1 targets a launch by the end of 2030 to the south polar region, near side. It carries two payloads, RSMA (up to 750 kg) and MRP (up to 200 kg). Each payload team defines its own surface mission; night survival is a goal [1][2]. In April 2026 ESA presented "the selection process for the first European Lunar landing site" [3]. MAGPIE is a 30 kg rover, prime ispace-Europe, planned for 2029, about 10 Earth days near the south pole [5]. Its ESA contract is EUR 65 million (news) [6].
  4. A European company sells rover capacity at the South Pole. Space Applications Services (Belgium) plans the first LUVMI-M mission for 2028: 20 kg of customer payload, up to 5 km of traverse in one lunar day, short entries into PSRs limited by thermal and energy margins. The company news item names the target as the Shackleton crater [8]; the EPSC 2026 abstract says only "the lunar South Pole region" [7]. The two sources also differ on the date: Q3 2028 in the news item, Q4 2028 in the abstract.
  5. Agencies state the terrain and lighting need themselves. ESA: "Landing safely on the Moon requires precise knowledge of the landscape below"; its Máni orbiter concept is to support landing-site assessment and route planning [4]. NASA: lighting changes over short distances, Earth must be visible until relays exist, and images at about 1 m/pixel are "not universally available across the polar regions" [14]. NASA's altimeter team names rover traverse planning and solar array height and location as uses of site DEMs [24].
  6. ESA's long-term infrastructure thinking is not centred on the South Pole. ESA summarised 33 submissions to its June 2025 Call for Evidence. Explore2040 foresees an "initial robotic infrastructure at a nearside primary location with Earth visibility" in the 2030s. The community favoured the nearside PKT. For polar regions it asked for prospecting missions before infrastructure planning, because the ice resource is uncertain [9].
  7. Polar robotics research lacks representative data. A University of Luxembourg team reports that image data representative of high lunar latitudes are lacking and that simulators reproduce polar light poorly; it built an analogue dataset for this reason [15]. A lists the existing simulators.
  8. Market forecasts exist but do not price site analysis. PwC (2021) put the lunar data market at USD 8.5 billion, cumulative 2020 to 2040, nominal case; it also noted that environment data are free after about six months and fragmented [16]. PwC (January 2026) forecasts USD 9.6 billion of energy investment for 2026 to 2050 and calls solar power "constrained at night and in polar regions"; it gives no data-market figure [17].
  9. NASA concentrates activity at the South Pole. Moon Base I targets the Shackleton Connecting Ridge, no earlier than autumn 2026. Two crewed rovers are due by 2028. The MoonFall drones will survey landing sites in 2028 [18]. NASA has its own tools (A, finding 4); it is context, not a first customer (judgement).
  10. Gap in the evidence. No source shows a user who says free tools are insufficient, or who would pay a third party for a site package. The unmet need is inferred from findings 2, 5 and 7 and from the absence of a European commercial supplier (A, finding 7). The published NASA illumination maps are 18.6-year averages at 60 to 240 m, not time series (B, section 3). Judgement.

3. Evidence table

"Letter" = realistic to approach for a letter of interest. All "Letter" entries except the first are judgement.

Organisation Type Mission or programme Current solution Unmet need Evidence Letter
Lithuanian company [TBD] Micro company, LT Solar panels for space and the Moon; applying to ESA Not known Illumination, power availability, thermal conditions at a site; to be confirmed with them Ivaylo (CLAUDE.md) Yes; in negotiation
Maana Electric Company, LU LUNABOX solar panels from regolith; SOURCE and ACME (heat for lunar night) with ESA Not found Site illumination and thermal inputs (judgement) [11] Unknown
Astrobotic, Honda Companies, US, JP LunaGrid power service; 10 kW and 50 kW arrays In-house simulation; LunaRay (A [30]) None stated; shows the need, met in-house [10] No; has own tools
ESA Argonaut Mission 1; Thales Alenia Space (lander prime) Agency; prime, IT Launch by end 2030; five-year surface design life ESA site-selection process, details not found; three illumination tools in 2012 (A [12]) Site selection; lander operations [1][3] ESA: no (staff cannot endorse). Prime: unknown
RSMA and MRP payload primes Industry; not yet known Argonaut Mission 1 payloads Not found Own surface mission: traverse, power, night survival [2] Unknown; winners not found
ispace-Europe Company, LU MAGPIE, 2029, ESA Moon Explore Not found; parent plans digital twins with SpaceData (A [32]) Driving in sunlit zones with entries into shadow [5][19] Unknown
Space Applications Services Company, BE LUVMI-M, 2028; payload service Tests at ESA LUNA and own Moon Yard Planning within thermal and energy limits [7][8] Unknown; has an open customer channel
Venturi Space Company, MC, FR Mona Luna rover, proposed for Argonaut, about 2030 Tests at ESA LUNA Not stated [20], news only Unknown; no confirmed flight
ESA Moonlight; NovaMoon study Programme Services from end 2028; South Pole priority DEM heights used in navigation analysis Not stated [21][22] No (ESA)
University of Luxembourg Research, LU Polar perception dataset; OmniLRS (A [28]) Analogue facility; procedural terrain Site-tied polar images with ground truth [15] Unknown; plausible
Aalborg University Research, DK Sizing and siting of solar microgrids near Shackleton Own illumination profiles from LOLA Validated illumination time series at finer scale (judgement) [12] Unknown; plausible
NASA Moon Base, Artemis Agency, US Moon Base I to III, LTV, MoonFall DUST, QuickMap, in-house (A) Not applicable [14][18] No

4. What this means for the Type A scope

  1. Supported: make illumination and darkness time series the lead derived product of the site package, at user-set heights above the surface and with stated uncertainty. Three user groups need it: power, rovers, landers [10][12][13][2]. Thermal layers stay at 240 m at best (B, finding 4); state this limit to power users.
  2. Supported: name Argonaut Mission 1, MAGPIE and LUVMI-M as the path beyond TRL 3. Their dates (2028 to 2030) follow a 9 to 15 month activity that starts in 2027 (judgement).
  3. Ruled out as the ESA link: site analysis for a permanent base. ESA's infrastructure thinking points to the nearside [9]; NASA serves its own base. Use "landing, mobility and power assets at a South Pole site".
  4. Site choice (open decision O9): user interest and data coverage point to the same area. LUVMI Mission 1, Moon Base I and the microgrid study target the Shackleton rim and Connecting Ridge [8][18][12]. B finds the most independent terrain products at Connecting Ridge. ESA NovaMoon slides list an example site at 89.48°S, 138.1°W, about 360 m from the Connecting Ridge site in B (estimate from the two coordinate pairs) [22]. The Argonaut site was not found.
  5. Position the product as paid analysis, not paid data. The source data are free [14][16]. Use the PwC figures as context only.

5. Ready-to-paste sentences

Re-check each against its source before use. Define acronyms again in the section where a sentence is used.

  1. The European Space Agency (ESA) targets a launch of Argonaut Mission 1 by the end of 2030 and a landing in the south polar region [1][2].
  2. ESA selected ispace-Europe to build MAGPIE, a 30 kg rover planned for launch in 2029 to search for water near the lunar south pole [5].
  3. Honda and Astrobotic agreed in 2025 to simulate one-year illumination profiles at lunar South Pole sites, to size solar arrays and energy storage [10].
  4. A 2023 study found that photovoltaic and battery mass varied from about 150,000 kg to 350,000 kg between lunar South Pole sites [12].
  5. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) states that image data at about one metre per pixel do not cover all polar areas [14].

6. Open risks and unknowns

Contradictions with CLAUDE.md, the RFI draft or A:

  1. CLAUDE.md section 5 states a preference for analysis "relevant to deploying a permanent base or a lander". ESA sources support the lander and rover case at the South Pole, not a European base there [9].
  2. CLAUDE.md section 4 says the product is sold to companies, academia and agencies. No evidence of willingness to pay was found. The closest users do the work in-house [10], and the source data are free [16].
  3. A (section 6, point 1) questions the "fragmented data" problem, because Moon Trek and QuickMap co-register layers. PwC (2021) lists fragmentation of environment data as a market obstacle [16]. Both hold; PwC is older and concerns resource data.
  4. B (section 4, point 5) says a site on the NASA list links better to current mission planning than Connecting Ridge. NASA's Moon Base I targets the Shackleton Connecting Ridge [18], so the ridge also has a current mission link.
  5. Dates differ. ESA pages give 2030 for Argonaut Mission 1 [1][2]; ESA navigation authors give 2031 [22]. The ESA page says the mission was to be proposed for funding in November 2025; the outcome was not confirmed in the sources opened.

Unknowns:

Decisions for Ivaylo: (a) replace the "permanent base" framing with landing, mobility and power assets; (b) which organisations to approach for letters before 23 November, besides the Lithuanian lead; suggested order (judgement): Space Applications Services, Maana Electric, one academic group; (c) ask Martin whether his laboratory could act as a research user [TBD].

7. Suggested follow-up topics

  1. Requirements of the Lithuanian lead: heights above the surface, time step, period, accuracy, thermal outputs, formats. Needed for 1.2; an interview, not web research.
  2. Sites targeted by Argonaut Mission 1, MAGPIE and LUVMI-M, and the data coverage at each (with follow-up B2 in B). Decides O9.
  3. The Argonaut RSMA and MRP calls: status, bidders, published requirements. Decides whom to name as a user in 1.6.1 and whom to approach.

8. Sources

Accessed 13 November 2026.

  1. ESA, Argonaut programme page (no date shown): https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Exploration/European_Large_Logistics_Lander
  2. ESA, Argonaut Mission 1 Payloads Day, 17 April 2026: https://atpi.eventsair.com/argonaut-mission-1-payloads-day
  3. ESA, Payloads Day objectives: https://atpi.eventsair.com/argonaut-mission-1-payloads-day/payloads-day-objectives
  4. ESA, Moon Explore missions, October 2026: https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Moon_Explore_sprinter_missions
  5. ESA, MAGPIE, October 2026: https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/MAGPIE_ESA_s_first_lunar_rover
  6. European Spaceflight, news, MAGPIE contract of EUR 65 million (extract): https://europeanspaceflight.com/esa-awards-ispace-e65m-contract-to-build-and-deliver-magpie-rover-to-the-moon/
  7. Winters et al., EPSC 2026 abstract, LUVMI-M: https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2026/EPSC2026-432.html
  8. Space Applications Services, LUVMI Mission 1, 29 September 2025: https://www.spaceapplications.com/news/space-applications-services-and-aerospace-applications-north-america-announce-first-lunar-surface-mission
  9. ESA, community perspective on regions for a future European lunar infrastructure (undated; file path June 2026): https://explorationscience.esa.int/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Community_Perspective_Potential_ROI_for_future_Infrastructure.pdf
  10. Astrobotic and Honda, press release, 29 September 2025: https://www.astrobotic.com/honda-and-astrobotic-establish-joint-development-agreement-to-explore-scalable-lunar-power-solutions/
  11. Luxembourg Space Agency directory, Maana Electric (no date shown): https://space-agency.public.lu/en/expertise/space-directory/MaanaElectric.html
  12. Saha et al. 2023, IEEE Access (abstract page): https://doaj.org/article/476c13866d4942f39d69226e9e890a4a ; related paper of the same group, Aalborg University repository (extract): https://vbn.aau.dk/ws/files/539404522/1-s2.0-S0273117722011644-main.pdf
  13. NASA Glenn, power beaming and relay tower study (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240014584/downloads/BEACON%20Final.pdf
  14. NASA, Lunar Site Selection white paper, 2023: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20230016267/downloads/Lunar%20Site%20Selection.pdf
  15. Rodríguez-Martínez et al., SPICE-HL3 dataset, 2026: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.22956 ; full text (extract): https://orbilu.uni.lu/bitstream/10993/68013/1/nature_scientific_data_2026_david_rodriguez.pdf
  16. PwC, Lunar market assessment, September 2021: https://www.pwc.com.au/industry/space-industry/lunar-market-assessment-2021.pdf
  17. PwC, Lunar market assessment, 2nd edition, January 2026: https://images.content.pwc.com/Web/PwCGlobal/%7Bfe86e29b-7590-4a9e-acf9-d7fdb3c55ba6%7D_FR_FY26_Lunar_Market_Assessment_Edition2_Download.pdf
  18. NASA, release 26-046, Moon Base update, 26 May 2026: https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-provides-update-on-moon-base-rovers-landers-missions/
  19. Casanova, IAC 2025 abstract, MAGPIE (extract): https://iafastro.directory/iac/paper/id/101508/abstract-pdf/IAC-25,D4,5,4,x101508.brief.pdf
  20. Payload, news, Mona Luna (extract): https://payloadspace.com/venturi-space-unveils-its-all-european-rover/
  21. ESA, Moonlight, 15 October 2024 (extracts): https://www.esa.int/Newsroom/Press_Releases/ESA_launches_Moonlight_to_establish_lunar_communications_and_navigation_infrastructure ; https://www.esa.int/Applications/Connectivity_and_Secure_Communications/ESA_s_Moonlight_programme_Pioneering_the_path_for_lunar_exploration
  22. Ventura-Traveset et al. (ESA), NovaMoon, Inside GNSS, 11 April 2025: https://insidegnss.com/?p=194941 ; slides: https://ioag.org/Cislunar%20PNT%20Workshop/6.%20Lunar%20PNT%20User,%20Test%20Equipment%20%26%20Technologies/07%20NOVAMOON_A%20LANS%20Monitoring%20and%20Local%20Differential%20Station_Dr%20Javier%20Ventura-Traveset.pdf
  23. ESA, RFI listing, 15 June 2026: https://explorationscience.esa.int/research-opportunities/request-for-information-commercial-lunar-data-products-for-exploration-science/
  24. Barker et al. 2021, Planetary and Space Science (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20205009660/downloads/Mike%20Barker_%20Paper_%20Improved%20Lola.pdf