Topic A2 — Competitors in depth: findings
14 November 2026. Second pass on the 21 items of
research/topics/A2-competitors.md, plus one item added by
Ivaylo the same day: the "Digital Twin of the Moon" initiative (item 22
here). Read research/findings/A-competitors.md first; this
file does not repeat it. Bracketed numbers refer to section 8 of this
file. "A:n" means source n of A-competitors.md. In section
8, "(local PDF)" marks a file read in
research/assets/topic-A/, "(extract)" a source read as a
search extract of the page, "(news)" and "(press release)" a non-primary
source. "Judgement" marks an assessment, not a sourced fact. "Unknown"
means searched and not found. Compiled with AI (Claude); not yet
re-checked by a person.
Length: about 5,300 words before the source list. This is over the
two-page limit of research-brief.md, because the request
was depth on 22 items.
Reading notes:
- The topic file has no Feeds line. Section 1 reuses the one of topic A.
- Item 3 reads "(*ip) 8, 9" with the numbers in square brackets. This file reads it as "in progress": A:8 (Moonraker) and A:9 (the ESA RFI). Say so if it meant something else.
- Strengths and weaknesses use one yardstick: a single tool with which a mission team can plan infrastructure deployment at a South Pole site. That means terrain, hazards, illumination and power, Earth and relay visibility, thermal environment, traverse and placement, with validation against measured data, stated uncertainty, and access for a European company.
Abbreviations not in glossary.md: OSIP = ESA Open Space
Innovation Platform; PGDA = NASA Planetary Geodesy Data Archive; SfS =
shape-from-shading; XR = extended reality; UE5 = Unreal Engine 5; CLPS =
NASA Commercial Lunar Payload Services; RF = radio frequency; GSD =
ground sample distance; ASP = NASA Ames Stereo Pipeline. Sources often
say DTM; this file uses DEM.
1. Feeds
1.4.1 State of the Art; 1.6.1 programmatic compliance (no
duplication); 1.6.2 Business Case Summary. Also the scope decision that
follows D17 in decisions-log.md (mission-planning software,
South Pole).
2. Key findings
- Mission planning for the South Pole is the function that most reviewed tools already target. (A further European initiative with the same aim is in finding 4.) In-house tools: CNES Spaceship FR [5]; DEMkit and LunaRay, now owned by Voyager Technologies [28][30][31]. Access by briefing only: MoonHacker [25]. Free web portals: Moon Trek [18] and QuickMap [19]. ESA-funded prototype: Milrem Robotics with Tartu Observatory [37][38]. A tool of this kind that a European company can license: not found.
- ADTLAS is a closed research project, not a funding scheme and not a planning tool. Fraunhofer FIT leads a named consortium of seven organisations, ESA included [1]. FusionLayer co-sponsors that research and supplies its own platform; the release offers nothing to third parties [3]. The stated work is XR augmentation of physical analogue testbeds and virtual replicas for remote review [1][2]. No call or access route for outside teams: not found [1][2][4].
- New relative to topic A: ESA funds a European mission-planning prototype for lunar rovers. Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory (Estonia) work under the ESA contract "Operations and mobility planning system for Lunar rover missions" [37]. News dates the signature to June 2021 [38]. The team plans points of interest and routes on 3D terrain of hundreds of square kilometres; an ESA employee co-authors the 2022 paper [37]. Tartu's ULYSSES simulator (UE5) models Sun, shadows, power and Earth-visibility windows [36]. Status after 2024: unknown.
- A European consortium proposes a "Digital Twin of the Moon" that names mission design among its uses; it is an initiative without secured funding, not a tool. TU Delft, DLR, Airbus Defence and Space, TerraSigna, SCN Avatar and ATG Europe form the core group, supported by the regions of Zuid-Holland and Bremen [43][44]. Stated uses: lunar science preparation; mission design with landing sites, routes and hazards; training; synthetic data for AI [43]. The members build components separately, and the page says the twin itself still needs funding [43]. A first version may come in 2026 or 2027; the target is 2030 onwards [43]. Data sources, target site, resolution, licence: not stated [43].
- Spaceship FR is an in-house CNES project at mock-up stage, not a product. In 2025 the authors called the results first building blocks and said the roadmap was still being defined [5]. Terrain, ephemeris and ray-cast illumination work; the "hyper datacube" (temperature, communications, radiation per surface point) is a concept [5]. The paper reports no validation against measured data and no uncertainty [5].
- DEMkit and LunaRay are the nearest functional match, and they sit inside a lander company. The 2022 paper lists DEM generation and alignment, procedural rocks and craters, visibility of Earth stations and relays, landing cost maps and physically based lighting, validated against orbiter images [28]. Astrobotic announced on 2 June 2026 that it would join Voyager Technologies [31]. Voyager's article of 22 October 2026 shows in-house use for the Griffin-1 site, not a sale to another company [30]. Price, licence and external customers: unknown.
- MoonHacker and RADSIM publish claims, not evidence. The sites list site selection, terrain analytics, thermal and radiation modelling, and payload digital twins [25][26]. They name no data sources, validation, customers or prices; access is by requested briefing or demo [25][26]. NASA's Spinoff article confirms that the company builds on NASA data [27].
- Open building blocks cover baseline steps 1 to 6.
Terrain with uncertainty: NASA PGDA [21], JAXA [24]. Methods with code:
SfS in ASP with height-error output, and the synthetic-terrain generator
synthterrain[23]; NASA's super-resolution code [22]; Project Chrono for sensor and terramechanics simulation [35]. Method without code: IllumNG illumination modelling [34]. Details in section 3.2. - Uncertainty is published for terrain, not for planning results (judgement on the gap). Height-uncertainty or height-error maps: [21][23][24]; per-pixel uncertainty for super-resolved terrain: [22]. No reviewed planning tool states an uncertainty on illumination, visibility or siting results: Spaceship FR [5], PANGU [9][10], DEMkit and LunaRay [28], MoonHacker [25]. This is absence in the sources read, not proof.
- EXPLORE L-Hex: the code was not found, and the end of the
platform says little about demand. The organisation's 21
repositories contain no L-Hex or L-Explo repository; the one
lunar-related repository is
DeepLandforms[14]. The platform site says it is discontinued and gives no reason [14]. The grant ended on 31 December 2023 (A:15). CORDIS reports use by community mapping groups and a data challenge [12]. Paying users: not found. - The team that operates the main lunar image source now works inside a lander company. Intuitive Machines announced on 18 May 2026 that it is prime contractor for operating LROC and ShadowCam, and that it plans lunar data services [20]. Effect on QuickMap terms: unknown.
3. Evidence
3.1 Tools that overlap with SELIS as mission-planning software
"Item" is the number in the topic file. Verdicts are judgements.
| Item | Tool; owner, country | Status and access, as of the source date | Strengths against the yardstick | Weaknesses against the yardstick | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 | Spaceship FR digital twin of the Moon; CNES, FR | In-house project in an ESA-coordinated network; CNES leads it since 2018 and funds staff with ESA [6]. First mock-up in Unity; move to Unreal Engine decided; roadmap being defined (2025) [5]. Licence and availability: unknown. Intended users: CNES teams and future operations teams [5]. | Planning is the stated purpose: illuminated rover paths, base siting [5]. Polar terrain at 5 m/pixel from LOLA, Sun ephemeris, ray-cast illumination over 1 to 10 years [5]. Path planner with slope limit and illumination; habitat-siting study used to size a power architecture [5]. | No validation against measured data; no uncertainty [5]. Rocks and craters are procedural and partly implemented [5]. Temperature, communications and radiation layers are a concept [5]. No Earth-visibility result [5]. | Research project and internal tool. Competes for attention at ESA; possible user of site data. |
| 1 | ADTLAS; Fraunhofer FIT with ESA and five companies, DE | Running. ESA record (section 6): OSIP activity, start 3 September 2025, 24 months, EUR 70,000. Closed consortium [1]. Outputs, data sources, licence: unknown. | Link to ESA and to analogue testing [1][2]. 3D topographic models of the lunar environment and of surface systems [1]. Builds on astronaut user studies [2]. | No illumination, visibility, hazard or planning function stated [1][4]. Focus is XR, human interaction and information-technology infrastructure [1][3]. | Complement. Low duplication risk if SELIS contains no XR, training or analogue-facility work. |
| 19 | Mission-planning system and ULYSSES simulator; Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory, EE | ESA contract, signed June 2021 (news) [38]. Results presented in 2022 [37]. ULYSSES described in July 2022 [36]. A 2024 Tartu thesis extends the route planner [37]. Current status, licence, availability: unknown. | Automatic planning of points of interest and routes on 3D terrain of hundreds of km² [37]. Time-dependent shadows in the route solver (2024 prototype) [37]. Simulator with Sun motion, shadows, solar power, battery, Earth-visibility windows and camera simulation [36]. | Built for rover traverses, not for fixed infrastructure (judgement from [37][38]). Demonstrated on the Apollo 15 site, not the South Pole [36]. Shadow check against one Apollo image [36]. | Closest ESA-funded European overlap. Competitor for traverse planning. |
| 22 | Digital Twin of the Moon (DT Moon); TU Delft, DLR, Airbus Defence and Space, TerraSigna, SCN Avatar, ATG Europe; NL and DE | Proposal by a core consortium, backed by two regions [43][44]. Roadmap 2025 to 2030: a Lunar Environment Reference Model proof of concept, then an immersive "Lunar Metaverse" proof of concept, then full development [43]. Members build components separately; the twin itself is not funded yet [43]. Described in November 2025 as still a vision [45]. Open to new members and to software building blocks [43]. Licence, price: not stated. | Widest European ambition: one multi-scale model with geometric and physical data, and an authoritative repository of lunar data [43]. Mission design is a named use: landing sites, navigation routes, hazards, contingency plans [43]. Members include an agency, a prime and a university [43]. The page names ESA, Airbus and OHB as stakeholders [43]. | No tool exists yet [43]. No data sources, site, resolution, illumination or visibility function, validation or uncertainty stated [43]. The whitepaper is a menu entry with no document behind it (14 November 2026). ESA funding or an ESA contract: not found. | Not a competitor today. The broadest future European overlap in name and aim. Possible route for SELIS as a building block. |
| 15 | DEMkit and LunaRay; Astrobotic, now Voyager Technologies, US | In flight-programme use: Griffin-1 site near Mons Mouton (22 October 2026) [30]. The 2022 paper says the tools serve "Astrobotic and customers" and names none [28]. Price, licence: unknown. | DEM generation, alignment to other elevation data, photometric correction [28]. Visibility of Earth stations and relays, landing cost maps [28]. Line-of-sight and solar-loading maps, rover path planning under constraints [29]. Lighting validated against orbiter images [28]. Site criteria used in practice: illumination, Earth visibility, slope, hazards [30]. | Owner sells lunar delivery, not software (judgement). No public product terms. Uncertainty of outputs not described [28]. Procedural rocks and craters; how they are tagged is not described [28]. | Closest functional competitor. Not shown to be sold as a product. |
| 14 | MoonHacker and RADSIM; Lunar Station Corp, US | Marketed to agencies, defence, primes and commercial users; access by requested briefing or demo [25][26]. Customers, price, data sources, validation: unknown. | Claims the widest scope: site selection, terrain analytics, comparison of sites and routes, thermal and radiation modelling [25]. Radiation simulation on digital twins of payloads and vehicles [26]. NASA Spinoff coverage [27]. | Nothing can be checked: no method, no validation, no named user [25][26]. Defence positioning may limit access from Europe (judgement; terms unknown). | Commercial competitor on paper. Evidence too thin to rank. |
| 9 | Moon Trek; NASA JPL, US | Operational, free, web. NASA authors report use for mission planning and site characterisation, including work with CLPS providers (2020) [18]. Which providers and decisions: unknown. | Many co-registered layers; lighting, slope, line-of-sight and traverse tools (A:19). Hosts third-party products such as MADNet DEMs [15]. | Fixed tool set in a portal. No per-cell provenance or uncertainty in outputs (judgement, as in topic A). | Free baseline. Every user will compare SELIS with it. |
| 10 | QuickMap; ASU LROC team and ACT, US | Operational, free, web. ACT also sells QuickMap deployments to teams [19]. LROC operations moved to Intuitive Machines in May 2026 [20]. Use of QuickMap itself in a named mission decision: not found. | Direct access to LROC products; slope and illumination tools [19]. Intuitive Machines calls the LROC archive a backbone for lunar mission planning [20]. | As Moon Trek. Future terms under the new operator: unknown. | Free baseline. Watch the operator change. |
| 8 | DUST; NASA JSC, US | Version 1.9. External users obtain it through a NASA Software User Agreement [17]. Eligibility of a Bulgarian company: unknown, not tested. | 3D South Pole scene with Sun and Earth geometry, slope maps and traverse view (A:18). Terrain at 5 m/pixel for the 87°S cap, plus 20 cm/pixel synthetic detail for areas of interest [17]. Free. | NASA describes it as an early reference for vendors' initial studies [17]. No analysis outputs with uncertainty. Synthetic detail. | Competitor for the 3D-scene function only. Cross-check for SELIS. |
| 5 | PANGU; University of Dundee and STAR-Dundee, UK | Version 7 (brochure of November 2023) [9]. Free for ESA projects after registration; other users buy a licence [9]. Public wiki shows a FAQ only, last edited June 2021 [11]. | Camera, lidar, radar and thermal-infrared simulation [9]. Imports DEMs, adds fractal detail, craters and boulders [9]. SPICE geometry, shadows, several reflectance models [9]. Height and slope maps, line-of-sight queries [9]. South Pole landing demonstration (Malapert) [11]. | No time-series illumination or visibility maps, no site analysis or planning function described [9]. Validation in the 2019 paper is visual, with no error figure; light scattered into shadow was not modelled [10]. | Not a planning competitor. Candidate component for synthetic images. |
| 16 | Cesium Moon Terrain; Cesium (Bentley Systems), US. Used in NASA Glenn's lunar RF model with Synopsys and Keysight | Released August 2024 as 3D Tiles [32]. Polar terrain at 5 m and imagery at 1 m per pixel; free for non-commercial use, paid plans for commercial use (news, 2024) [32]. | Ready 3D base layer with plug-ins for Unreal Engine and Unity [32]. The NASA model finds RF shadow zones and supports radio placement [33]. | Base layer only: no illumination, thermal or hazard analysis, no uncertainty [32]. The RF tools are commercial US software [33]. | Resource for viewing. Partial competitor for communications planning. |
| 6 | EXPLORE L-Hex; ACRI-ST consortium, EU | Grant ended 31 December 2023 (A:15). Platform discontinued; the site says the applications remain on ESA Datalabs (not verified) [14]. L-Hex code: not found [14]. | Web access to lunar data for landing-site characterisation and traverse design, 2D to 3D views [13]. Used in a lunar traverse data challenge [12]. | Data access and display, not simulation; no illumination or visibility function stated [13]. | Not a competitor. |
| 4 | LandSAfe; Leibniz University Hannover, University of Liège, Spacebel, ESA | ESA contract; described in 2012 [7]. Later status and availability: unknown. | One framework for NAC stereo DEMs tied to LOLA, hazard, illumination, temperature and reflectance maps, and risk maps; web client and server [7]. Shackleton rim example [7]. | No product or download found. Accuracy assessment was future work in 2012 [7]. | Prior ESA work. Cite it; do not present its chain as new. |
3.2 Technology, methods and data that SELIS can build on
These are not competitors. "Use for SELIS" is a judgement.
| Item | Resource; owner | What it gives | Access and licence, as read on 14 November 2026 | Use for SELIS | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | PGDA LOLA site DEMs; NASA GSFC | DEMs at 5 m/pixel with height- and slope-uncertainty maps and
statistical clones [21]; details in
B-data-sets.md |
Open download [21]; licence terms in
B-data-sets.md |
Measured terrain reference; clones allow uncertainty to be carried into derived layers | About 10% of 5 m pixels hold a LOLA return
(B-data-sets.md) |
| 11 | PGDA SfS terrain; NASA GSFC | SfS DEMs at 5 m/pixel for South Pole regions [21] | Open download [21] | Input and comparison for the measured or derived class | SfS output depends on the images and the reflectance model |
| 11 | Super-resolution with a diffusion Schrödinger bridge; Repasky et al., NASA GSFC | 16-times super-resolution of DEM patches, constrained by images, with per-pixel uncertainty [22] | Code on Zenodo and GitHub, CC BY 4.0, about 338 kB, without trained weights or data [22] | Candidate method for the inferred class, with its own uncertainty | Trained on rendered images, not real ones [22]. Training cost unknown. Overlaps with ESA's OSIP DEM projects (A:6) |
| 12 | LuNaMaps tools; NASA GSFC, ARC, JPL | SfS maps at 1 m/pixel in ASP with a height-error product; Rocky
Surface Generator; synthterrain; map-validation tools [23] |
ASP is open source; synthterrain is released on GitHub;
other scripts are planned for public release [23].
Licences not checked |
Procedure for the measured and synthetic classes; validation approach (SfS against LOLA) | Aimed at terrain-relative navigation, not at planning [23] |
| 13 | LUPEX landing-site terrain; Hemmi and Inoue, JAXA | SfS DEMs, orthomosaics and height-uncertainty maps for six regions, with a processing script [24] | Zenodo, CC BY 4.0, 12.1 GB [24] | Data set and worked example for metre-scale DEMs with uncertainty | Six fixed regions; method needs suitable NAC images |
| 7 | MADNet; UCL Mullard Space Science Laboratory | Single-image deep-learning DEMs at 1 m/pixel; South Pole products for 7 of 13 Artemis regions [15]; von Kármán mosaic with stated differences to reference DEMs [16] | Products through the ESA Guest Storage Facility and Moon Trek [15][16]. Code: not found; the authors call it in-house [16] | Possible inferred-class input; comparison data | No code to reuse. South Pole coverage is partial [15] |
| 17 | IllumNG; Mazarico et al., NASA GSFC | Ray-traced illumination with extended Sun, Earthshine and scattered light; validated against NAC images [34] | Method published; code and licence: not stated in the paper [34] | Reference method and validation recipe for the derived illumination layer | No thermal model [34]. Re-implementation needed |
| 18 | Project Chrono lunar sensor simulation; University of Wisconsin-Madison | Camera simulation with a lunar reflectance model, coupled to terramechanics; tested on NASA analogue image sets [35] | Open source on GitHub [35]; licence not checked | Synthetic sensor data from a site package, if that enters the scope | No procedural terrain; needs an NVIDIA GPU; reflectance model not validated on lunar images [35] |
| 4 | LandSAfe and the ESA Lunar Lander site study | Method chain [7]; cross-check of illumination by three independent tools [8] | Papers only [7][8] | Precedent to cite in 1.4.1; the three-tool cross-check is a validation pattern | Software not available |
| 6 | DeepLandforms; EXPLORE |
Tool set for training landform segmentation models [14] | GitHub, GNU GPL v3.0 [14] | Possible hazard-feature detection | GPL obligations if distributed; fitness for the South Pole unknown |
| 5 | PANGU | Sensor-image simulation on imported DEMs [9] | Free for ESA projects after registration [9] | Synthetic images without building a renderer | Terms for use in a PECS contract must be confirmed with STAR-Dundee |
| 16 | Cesium Moon Terrain and 3D Tiles | Streamed 3D base layer; open tile format [32] | Account; paid for commercial use (news, 2024) [32] | Viewer base, with a site package added on top | US commercial service; a subscription is a tool cost, check eligibility |
| 20, 21 | Moonraker; NUVIEW GmbH with SFL Missions and DLR | Planned lunar lidar: polar regions at 4 m GSD, plus a high-resolution mode (extract) [41]; DLR is to produce the elevation maps (extract) [41] | ESA Pre-Phase A [39], then Phase A, announced 16 June 2026 [40]; launch 2030 (news) [41]. Data policy: unknown | Future measured input; link to future missions for 1.6 | No data before 2030 at the earliest |
| 3 | ESA RFI "Commercial Lunar Data Products for Exploration Science" | Sign that ESA considers buying lunar data products [42] | Published June 2026 [42] | Context only | Not ESA interest in SELIS (CLAUDE.md section 3) |
3.3 Answers to the topic items
- ADTLAS. It is research by a fixed consortium under ESA's OSIP [1][3]. FusionLayer pays into that research and provides its platform; it does not fund third parties [3]. The annual-report page states no opportunity for outside researchers [2]. Benefit for a PECS proposal: name ADTLAS in 1.4.1 and 1.6.1 as a complemented activity. Duplication: low, on condition (table 3.1). Residual risk: the shared words "digital twin" and "lunar environment".
- Spaceship FR. Research and in-house tool, not a product (table 3.1).
- Items A:8 and A:9. Both are context, not competitors (table 3.2).
- LandSAfe and De Rosa et al. No product found. Both are usable as precedent and as method sources (tables 3.1 and 3.2).
- PANGU. A navigation-sensor simulator, not a planning tool (table 3.1). The wiki holds no technical content [11].
- EXPLORE L-Hex. The topic file assumes the source is
available. It was not found (finding 10). Reuse is limited to
DeepLandforms. The reason for the end: not stated; the end of the grant is the only dated fact. - MADNet. Research with published data products; no software product and no code found (table 3.2).
- DUST. Not only for NASA: NASA offers it to external users under an agreement [17]. One paper calls it not publicly available [35]. Whether a Bulgarian company qualifies: unknown. A European equivalent that a company can obtain: not found. This supports a European-capability argument, as "not found" only.
- Moon Trek. NASA authors report mission-planning use, including with CLPS providers [18]. It is also a public and outreach portal. Named users and decisions: unknown.
- QuickMap. Same pattern; ACT sells team deployments [19]. A named mission decision made with QuickMap: not found.
- PGDA products. Resources, not competitors (table 3.2).
- LuNaMaps. A NASA project that produces navigation maps and tools; it helps SELIS and does not indicate a commercial competitor [23].
- JAXA LUPEX terrain. A data set and a worked method, not a competitor [24].
- MoonHacker and RADSIM. Close in claimed scope; not verifiable (table 3.1).
- LunaRay and DEMkit. Closest functional match. The Voyager article shows in-house use after the acquisition, not use by another company [30][31].
- Cesium Moon and "Lunar 3GPP". The second is a NASA Glenn project, not a product. It combines Cesium terrain with commercial RF tools from Synopsys and Keysight [33]. All parties are in the USA. A European equivalent for lunar RF planning: not searched.
- IllumNG. A method to build on; code not found (table 3.2).
- Chrono. Open-source software to build on (table 3.2).
- ULYSSES. Part of an ESA-funded Estonian line of work on rover mission planning (finding 3). 20, 21. SFL Missions, NUVIEW and Moonraker. A future data source and a link to ESA's plans, not a competitor (table 3.2).
- Digital Twin of the Moon (added item). An initiative, not a product: it is at the proposal and proof-of-concept stage and seeks funding [43][44]. It is regional and industrial, not an ESA activity; a 2024 workshop addressed ESA representatives to compare it with ESA, EU and national agendas (news) [45]. Its scope is far wider than a Type A activity. It invites organisations with software building blocks to make contact [43].
Follow-up topics carried over from A-competitors.md
section 7:
- The five 2023 OSIP projects: contractors, deliverables and licences are still not found. Searches by project title returned nothing; the ESA activities portal needs a login.
- Spaceship FR and ADTLAS: answered above as far as public sources go. Outputs and availability remain unknown.
- MoonHacker and LunaRay: customers and prices remain unknown. Access for European users: unknown.
4. What this means for the Type A scope
All five points are judgements.
- "Mission-planning software for the South Pole" (D17) cannot be the novelty claim. The function exists at CNES, at Voyager, at Lunar Station, in NASA's portals and in an ESA-funded Estonian prototype. A Dutch-German consortium also proposes a Europe-wide digital twin of the Moon with mission design as a use. The proposal must name them in 1.4.1.
- The supported gap is planning results that carry terrain uncertainty and data class through to the decision. Example: a siting result for a power or communications asset that states how sure it is, and is checked against measured data. No reviewed tool documents this; the inputs for it are open ([21][23][24]).
- Rule out as core work, or enter only as a user: XR and training (ADTLAS); rover route optimisation (Milrem and Tartu); a navigation image simulator (PANGU); new DEM or super-resolution methods (PGDA, UCL, JAXA, the OSIP projects); RF propagation modelling (NASA Glenn).
- Reuse instead of rebuilding: PGDA and JAXA terrain; ASP for SfS;
synthterrainfor the synthetic class; the IllumNG paper as method and validation recipe; Chrono or PANGU if synthetic sensor data enters the scope; 3D Tiles for viewing. This keeps a EUR 200,000 activity on the research question. - Business case: the nearest US tools are in-house, briefing-gated or under a NASA agreement. A European supplier was not found. State this as "not found in a review of November 2026", and do not claim export restrictions; none was confirmed.
5. Ready-to-paste sentences
Re-check each against its source before use. Define acronyms again in the section where a sentence is used.
- The Centre National d'Études Spatiales (CNES) reported in 2025 that its lunar digital twin was a first mock-up with terrain, ephemeris and illumination functions [5].
- Fraunhofer FIT leads ADTLAS, which uses extended reality to augment lunar analogue testbeds; its project page names no site-analysis or mission-planning function [1].
- Researchers of the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) published metre-scale terrain models with height-uncertainty maps for six South Pole regions, licensed CC BY 4.0 [24].
- Mazarico and co-authors validated the IllumNG ray-tracing tool against Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter Camera images, with correlation above 0.9 in permanently shadowed regions [34].
- Astrobotic described DEMkit and LunaRay in 2022 as tools that compute lighting, Earth visibility and landing cost maps from lunar terrain data [28].
6. Open risks and unknowns
Contradictions with CLAUDE.md,
decisions-log.md, A-competitors.md or the
topic file:
- D17 fixes the direction as mission-planning software. That is the most occupied function in this review (finding 1). It raises the duplication risk in 1.6.1 unless the scope is narrowed as in section 4.
A-competitors.mdnames Spaceship FR as the closest European overlap. For planning, the ESA contract with Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory is as close, and ESA funds it directly [37][38]. Topic A missed it.A-competitors.mdlists LunaRay and DEMkit under Astrobotic. The owner is now Voyager Technologies [31]. The topic file reads the Voyager article as use by another company; it is in-house use [30].- The topic file states that the L-Hex source is available on GitHub. No L-Hex repository was found there [14].
CLAUDE.mdpresents the synthetic and inferred classes as SELIS features. NASA'ssynthterrainand Rocky Surface Generator, DEMkit and PANGU already generate synthetic rocks and craters [23][28][9]. NASA's super-resolution method already reports per-pixel uncertainty for inferred terrain [22]. The four-class rule has partial precedents; the claim must be the combined, per-cell treatment.CLAUDE.mdbaseline step 2 uses NAC stereo. LuNaMaps and JAXA use SfS at the South Pole [23][24]. Same finding as in topics A and B.- Two wording issues left open in
A-competitors.mdare now settled. The JAXA record does list height-uncertainty maps [24]. The LandSAfe paper does use NAC stereo [7]. CLAUDE.mdrule 10 fixes "digital twin" as a SELIS term. "Digital twin of the Moon" is now the name of a CNES tool and of a Dutch-German initiative with agency and prime members [43]. A small Bulgarian proposal under the same label invites comparison with both (judgement).
Unknowns:
- ADTLAS: data sources, outputs, licence, and whether a site package would be useful to it. The start date, duration and budget come from https://activities.esa.int/node/4142 . A browser gets a login page there; a direct fetch returned the content on 13 and 14 November 2026. Do not use these figures in proposal text until a person has opened the page.
- Spaceship FR: availability outside CNES, current roadmap, and ESA's role beyond co-funding staff [6].
- Milrem and Tartu: contract value, end date, deliverables, later ESA contracts, licence of ULYSSES.
- Digital Twin of the Moon: funding source and amount, ESA's position, data sources, first site, the role of each member, and what the announced whitepaper contains [43]. The initiative is not an ESA activity as far as the sources show, so the call's duplication rule may not apply to it formally; an evaluator may still know it (judgement).
- Voyager: whether DEMkit and LunaRay are sold or licensed, and at what price.
- Lunar Station: customers, prices, data sources, validation, access from Europe. A news item of 13 August 2026 (A:31) did not open for me.
- DUST: eligibility of non-US companies.
- QuickMap and LROC data services under Intuitive Machines: future terms.
- Whether any published tool carries DEM uncertainty into illumination or visibility results. Not searched as a question of its own (follow-up 1).
- Voyager's completion date for the Astrobotic acquisition was seen in news only and is not cited.
- Link check, 14 November 2026, in Ivaylo's browser: the links of section 8 that topic A had not already tested were opened, except those supplied in the topic file. All opened except two (the three added for item 22 opened too). The Moon Trek abstract (confit.atlas.jp) showed a maintenance page; try again later. The ESA activities record needs a login (see the ADTLAS line above). Three addresses were replaced by the page they redirect to, and two sources that did not open were dropped or replaced.
- Sources read as extracts or news are marked in section 8. Re-open them before any sentence built on them enters the proposal.
Decisions for Ivaylo:
- (a) Accept, change or reject the narrowed claim in section 4, point 2, as input to the grilling session.
- (b) Whether rover traverse planning stays in the scope, given the Estonian ESA contract.
- (c) Whether to contact Fraunhofer FIT, CNES Spaceship FR or Tartu Observatory as possible users. Rule: no ESA staff member may be cited as adviser or endorser.
- (d) Whether a person with an ESA OSIP account can read the activity records for ADTLAS and the five OSIP projects.
- (e) Whether to contact the Digital Twin of the Moon initiative, which invites building blocks, and whether to name it in 1.6.1 as a complemented activity.
- (f) Whether "digital twin" stays the headline term (also decision
(c) in
A-competitors.md).
7. Suggested follow-up topics
- Uncertainty in planning results: does any published work carry DEM uncertainty into illumination, visibility or siting results at the South Pole? It decides whether the claim in section 4 survives (1.4.1, 1.1 objectives).
- ESA-funded lunar surface planning and simulation work in ESA Member and Cooperating States since 2021: contracts, contractors, results. The Estonian contract was found by chance; others may exist (1.6.1).
- The five 2023 OSIP projects, through an ESA OSIP account or a question to ESA: who, what, which licence. Still open from topic A (1.6.1, work packages).
8. Sources
Accessed 14 November 2026 unless a different date is given. Link check in section 6.
- Fraunhofer FIT, ADTLAS project page: https://www.fit.fraunhofer.de/en/business-areas/cooperation-systems/projects/adtlas.html
- Fraunhofer FIT, Annual Report 2025, "XR and Digital Twins for Lunar Missions": https://www.fit.fraunhofer.de/en/publikationen/annual-report-2025/XR-and-Digital-Twins-for-Lunar-Missions.html
- FusionLayer release on ADTLAS, Business Wire, 26 February 2026 (press release): https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260226842277/en/FusionLayer-the-European-Space-Agency-and-Fraunhofer-FIT-Collaborate-on-ADTLAS-Project-to-Pioneer-Digital-Infrastructure-for-Future-Lunar-Missions
- Fraunhofer FIT, space research page: https://www.fit.fraunhofer.de/en/business-areas/cooperation-systems/mixed-reality/space-research.html ; LUNA Analog Facility (DLR and ESA): https://luna-analog-facility.de/en/ ; ESA, "Extended reality at ESA opens new pathways for space exploration", 7 May 2026: https://www.esa.int/articles/extended-reality-at-esa-opens-new-pathways-for-space-exploration . None of the three mentions ADTLAS outputs or a planning tool.
- Navarro, Malapert, Costantini, Paillet, "Hyper Datacube for a Digital Twin of the Moon to plan and support operations", SpaceOps 2025, paper 211 (local PDF): https://publications.spaceops.org/2025/download_by_id.php?id=0211
- CNES, Spaceship FR project page (extract): https://cnes.fr/projets/spaceship ; English version: https://cnes.fr/en/projects/spaceship
- Schmidt et al. 2012, "LandSAfe: Landing Site Risk Analysis Software Framework" (local PDF): https://isprs-archives.copernicus.org/articles/XXXIX-B4/505/2012/
- De Rosa et al. 2012, "Characterisation of potential landing sites for the European Space Agency's Lunar Lander project" (local PDF): https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.5587
- PANGU v7 brochure, 26 November 2023: https://pangu.software/wp-content/pangu_uploads/pdfs/PANGU_v7_Brochure_Issue-1.00_2023nov26.pdf
- Martin, Dunstan, Sanchez Gestido, Space Imaging Workshop 2019: https://pangu.software/wp-content/pangu_uploads/pdfs/SpaceImagingWorkshop_2019_paper_pangu_final.pdf
- PANGU wiki: https://pangu.software/wiki/Main_Page ; PANGU videos: https://pangu.software/videos/
- CORDIS, EXPLORE results (extract): https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101004214/reporting
- Nodjoumi et al., EPSC2022-966, "EXPLORE Lunar Scientific Data Applications: L-Explo and L-Hex" (extract): https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2022/EPSC2022-966.html
- EXPLORE platform site: https://explore-platform.eu ; GitHub organisation: https://github.com/explore-platform
- Muller, Tao et al., EPSC2024-1170: https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2024/EPSC2024-1170.html
- Tao et al. 2023, Remote Sensing 15, 2643 (extract): https://www.mdpi.com/2072-4292/15/10/2643 ; ESA Planetary Science Archive, data set page (extract): https://www.cosmos.esa.int/web/psa/ucl-mssl_moon_von_karman_v1.0
- NASA, Prototype Immersive Technologies Lab, DUST: https://www.nasa.gov/general/prototype-immersive-technologies-lab/ ; NASA Software Catalog: https://software.nasa.gov/software/MSC-27522-1
- Moon Trek, JpGU 2020 abstract PPS02-P12 (extract): https://confit.atlas.jp/guide/event/jpgu2020/subject/PPS02-P12/date ; NASA NTRS record (13 November 2026): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20220010585
- Applied Coherent Technology, QuickMap (extract): https://www.actgate.com/examples/lroc-quickmap
- Intuitive Machines, release of 18 May 2026 (press release, extract): https://investors.intuitivemachines.com/news-releases/news-release-details/intuitive-machines-announces-two-prime-lunar-reconnaissance
- NASA PGDA, LOLA site DEMs and SfS terrain (13 November 2026): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/78 ; https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/81 ; https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/104
- Repasky et al., code record: https://zenodo.org/records/14170310 ; repository: https://github.com/mrepasky3/topography_sr_schrodinger ; paper, 12 June 2026: https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.14638 ; PGDA page (13 November 2026): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/106
- NASA, LuNaMaps Technology Transfer Plan v1.1, 30 August 2024 (local PDF): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240012328/downloads/LuNaMaps_TechTransfer.pdf
- Hemmi and Inoue, LUPEX landing-site terrain, 25 September 2025: https://zenodo.org/records/17153447 ; JAXA page (13 November 2026): https://jlpeda.jaxa.jp/en/product/archive/detail_14/
- Lunar Station Corp, MoonHacker: https://www.moonhacker.space/ ; company site: https://lunarstation.space
- Lunar Station Corp, RADSIM: https://www.radsim.net/
- NASA Spinoff, Lunar Station (13 November 2026): https://www.nasa.gov/technology/tech-transfer-spinoffs/nasa-data-helps-commercial-space-plan-living-off-our-moon/
- Hough et al., "DEMkit & LunaRay: Tools for Mission Data Generation and Validation", Space Imaging Workshop 2022 (local PDF): https://seal.ae.gatech.edu/sites/default/files/2022-10/SIW22-22_0.pdf
- Astrobotic, simulation toolkit sheet hosted by NASA (13 November 2026): https://smd-cms.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-landing-simulation-toolkits.pdf
- Voyager Technologies, "How Voyager chose Griffin's lunar landing site", 22 October 2026: https://voyagertechnologies.com/insights/how-voyager-chose-griffins-lunar-landing-site/
- Astrobotic, release on joining Voyager Technologies, 2 June 2026 (press release): https://www.astrobotic.com/astrobotic-to-join-voyager-technologies-accelerating-americas-moon-base/
- Cesium, Cesium Moon Terrain: https://cesium.com/platform/cesium-ion/content/cesium-moon-terrain ; Geo Week News, 6 August 2024 (news, extract): https://www.geoweeknews.com/articles/cesium-moon-tiles-3d-geospatial-nasa-lunar-rover-simulation/ ; CG Channel, 11 August 2024 (news, extract; resolution and price): https://www.cgchannel.com/2024/08/create-a-cg-moon-in-ue5-with-the-free-cesium-moon-terrain-data/
- Synopsys blog, RF digital twin of the Moon: https://www.synopsys.com/blogs/chip-design/rf-digital-twin-of-the-moon.html ; RCR Wireless, 27 April 2026 (news): https://www.rcrwireless.com/20260427/test-measurement/inside-nasas-lunar-network-built-on-synopsys-digital-twins
- Mazarico, Barker, Nicholas 2018, Advances in Space Research 62(11): https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6398960
- Batagoda et al. 2024, Chrono lunar sensor simulation: https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.04371 ; code: https://github.com/projectchrono/chrono
- Tartu Observatory team, "ULYSSES", 20 July 2022 (blog by the developers): https://space-travel.blog/ulysses-1f4342d04f66
- IAC-22,A3,2B,15,x73873, "Large scale mobility on the Moon by transferring terrestrial autonomy capabilities" (extract): https://dl.iafastro.directory/event/IAC-2022/paper/73873/ ; Ilves 2024, University of Tartu bachelor's thesis (extract): https://ims.ut.ee/www-public2/at/2024/bsc/june/atprog-bakalaureuset55-loti.05.029-Uku_Ilves-text-20240601.pdf
- Electronic Specifier on the Milrem Robotics contract with ESA, 2021 (news, extract): https://www.electronicspecifier.com/industries/aerospace-defence/autonomous-capabilities-for-planetary-rovers-on-the-moon/ ; Science|Business, Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory release (news, extract): https://sciencebusiness.net/network-updates/milrem-robotics-and-tartu-observatory-start-developing-moon-rovers
- SFL Missions release, 10 June 2025 (press release): https://sflmissions.com/sfl-missions-inc-included-on-team-awarded-moon-mapping-study-contract-by-european-space-agency-esa/
- NUVIEW release, PR Newswire, 16 June 2026 (press release): https://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/nuview-selected-by-esa-in-next-phase-of-lunar-lidar-mission-302799621.html
- Payload, 14 July 2026 (news): https://payloadspace.com/lunar-outpost-tapped-for-esas-moonraker-mission-in-2030/ ; Small Satellites Europe 2026 abstract (extract): https://2026.smallsateurope.com/paper/moonraker-de-risking-lunar-landing-sites-with-high-resolution-lidar/ ; SpaceOps 2025, paper 616 (extract): https://publications.spaceops.org/2025/download_by_id.php?id=0616
- ESA, RFI listing (13 November 2026): https://explorationscience.esa.int/research-opportunities/request-for-information-commercial-lunar-data-products-for-exploration-science/
- Digital Twin of the Moon initiative, project site made by ATG-Europe, copyright 2025: https://www.aviaspace-bremen.de/wp-content/uploads/DTMoon/index.html
- AVIASPACE BREMEN, Digitalisation page: https://www.aviaspace-bremen.de/en/digitalisation/
- AVIASPACE BREMEN, panel announcement, 20 November 2025: https://www.aviaspace-bremen.de/events/panel-towards-a-digital-twin-of-the-moon-a-new-era-in-lunar-exploration/ ; NL Space Campus, on the workshop of November 2024 (news, extract): https://www.nlspacecampus.eu/news/dutch-space-sector-at-space-tech-expo-europe-showcasing-expertise-and-growing-networks/