SELIS V2

Decisions log — SELIS V2

Newest entries at the bottom. Each entry: date, decision or fact, reason or source. When an entry changes CLAUDE.md, update that file too.

2026-11-13

Facts confirmed by Ivaylo

# Fact Source
F1 Applicant is Luminous Ltd, registered and approved on esa-star. Ivaylo
F2 SELIS stands for Site Environment & Landing Infrastructure Simulator. Ivaylo
F3 Official closing is 26 November 2026, 13:00 Amsterdam time (14:00 in Sofia). Ivaylo's working deadline is 25 November. ESA cover letter point 13; Ivaylo
F4 Type A constraints: start TRL at least 1, end TRL at most 3, 9 to 15 months, firm fixed price up to EUR 200,000, end-customer highly encouraged. The overall threshold for Type A is 55, not 50. ESA cover letter points 4 and 7c
F5 Evaluation weights are 40% technical and team, 30% prospects and maturity, 25% management, cost and planning, 5% administrative and IPR compliance. call-docs/ESA - TA Information.txt
F6 Current state is early feasibility only: Ames Stereo Pipeline set up locally and DEMs produced from stereo pairs, NASA DEMs and LROC PDS archive explored, Rhino Grasshopper PV-potential demos on generated DEMs. Ivaylo
F7 The RFI response was submitted; Bulgarian entities were not eligible; ESA replied that it is reviewing the project. Ivaylo
F8 Key personnel so far: Ivaylo Tsankov and Martin Ivanov. Martin's CV is pending. Ivaylo
F9 Only one potential customer so far: a Lithuanian micro company developing solar panels for space and the Moon, also applying to ESA. In negotiation. Ivaylo
F10 Proposal limit is 25 pages, excluding cover letter, PSS forms and annexes. Annexes are not marked. ESA cover letter point 8c
F11 AI use must be disclosed in cover letter point 9 (proposal elements) and section 2.4.3 (deliverables). Tendering conditions 4.2; proposal template
F12 The clarification-question window closed on 12 November 2026 (14 calendar days before closing). ESA cover letter point 12
F13 Non-Bulgarian entities may take part only where justified, not for core work, with subcontracts at most 20% of the price. Lithuania has been an ESA Associate Member since 21 May 2021. ESA cover letter point 2; ESA news release
F14 Type A is fully funded; profit at most 8% of PSS A2 item 9. Procurement of infrastructure and generic tools is out of scope. ESA cover letter points 4 and 6; proposal template 3.2.1
F15 TRL 3 means an analytical and experimental proof of concept of critical functions; TRL 4 is breadboard validation in a laboratory environment. ESA's Technical Officer verifies the TRL at the end. Draft contract, Appendix 4
F16 At most 2 proposals as prime and 3 in total per entity under this call. ESA cover letter point 9
F17 Duplication of ongoing or intended ESA activities leads to a programmatic down-mark and possible rejection. ESA cover letter point 6
F18 Transfer of IP arising from the work to an entity outside Bulgaria needs prior authorisation of the Bulgarian government, requested through ESA. Draft contract 6.5
F19 Luminous Ltd expressed interest in the call in esa-star on 13 November 2026. Ivaylo
F20 Luminous Ltd is registered as an SME in esa-star, so it is entitled to a 35% advance payment. Ivaylo; proposal template 3.2.2
F21 README.md and AGENTS.md are symlinks to CLAUDE.md, which is the master file. Ivaylo
F22 ESA published nine clarifications (26 October to 12 November 2026). None changes the deadline, limits or criteria. call-docs/clarifications/
F23 Cloud processing and similar activity-specific recurring costs are in principle eligible (PSS A2 items 3.1 to 3.7 or 3.10, plus Exhibit A). Infrastructure, including upgrades and depreciation, is not. Clarifications 9.3 and 2.1
F24 Letters of interest from prospective users may be annexed and are considered in the evaluation. A subcontract with the end customer is encouraged but not required for Type A. Clarification 9.6
F25 A subcontractor cannot be shown at zero cost; it needs its own PSS forms and may waive payment on PSS A2 line 14. Clarifications 1.1 and 3.2
F26 The start TRL is assessed at the level of the system being developed, justified from component maturity and demonstrated integration. Clarification 9.4
F27 A Type A proposal should substantiate the path beyond TRL 3: mission, end users, business case, state of the art. A named mission or user strengthens it but is not required. Clarification 9.2
F28 Owner-manager labour may be budgeted for Type A if the person is actually paid by the company; rates are assessed by the TEB; no prior rate agreement is needed. Economic conditions year may be 2027. Clarifications 5.6, 6.4 and 7.1
F29 ESA staff cannot act as advisers to a tenderer or endorse a proposal. Clarification 6.5
F30 Background IP needed for the activity must be declared even if not delivered. No general open-source obligation. The contractor keeps commercial exploitation rights, subject to ESA's rights. Clarifications 8.1 to 8.4 and 9.5
F31 Luminous Ltd is an EOOD. Ivaylo Tsankov is its sole owner and manager, is self-insured, is paid by the company, and is currently the only person paid by it. Ivaylo
F32 Martin Ivanov is not currently engaged by Luminous Ltd. He works hybrid and can do his SELIS work from Bulgaria. An employment or civil-law contract can be set up. Ivaylo
F33 PSS instructions: rates follow the company's normal accounting practice and are marked provisional or definitive; rates not agreed with ESA are subject to negotiation; ESA may audit. A supplier under item 3.7 (external services, including consultancies) cannot be responsible for a work package. call-docs/PSSA1_i5.xlsx, PSSA2_i5.xlsx, Instructions sheets

Decisions

# Decision Reason
D1 Apply under Type A (Research and Preparatory Activities). Matches the maturity of the idea and the current state (F6).
D2 Luminous Ltd is the prime. No subcontractors, academic partners or advisers for now; add one only if critical to success. Keep the consortium simple; revisit after scope is set.
D3 IP towards ESA follows the ESA contract conditions; everything else is retained by Luminous Ltd. Intended future market: private companies, academia, possibly other agencies. Ivaylo's position.
D4 The call documents are kept as blank templates; nothing is carried over from the RFI draft automatically. Clean slate, so the proposal is built for PECS, not adapted from the RFI.
D5 Scope will be derived from the Type A definition, the guide, the budget and the timeline, and only then mapped onto the SELIS vision. The full vision does not fit a Type A activity.
D6 Feature research is allowed (topic E in research-brief.md), with innovation permitted where grounded in existing data, published methods and a credible verification path; each feature gets an evidence grade and B and C features need a fallback. An early-stage project benefits from exploring options, but the proposal must stay deliverable.
D7 Working rule for all chats: call documents first, playbook second, CLAUDE.md third; no invented facts; unknowns marked [TBD]. Set in the project instructions.
D8 Internal target: submittable proposal by 23 November, two days before the deadline. Margin for forms, signatures and upload problems.
D9 Proposal text follows a plain technical English rule set derived from ASD-STE100 (sentence and paragraph limits, active voice with named actor, one term per thing, no vague qualifiers). Full STE compliance is not claimed or attempted. Clarity is part of the 40% criterion and evaluators may be non-native readers; full STE needs a licensed dictionary, suits manuals not proposals, and cannot be verified by the agents.
D10 Glossary moved from CLAUDE.md to glossary.md, which is the single source for terms. Keeps CLAUDE.md short and gives rule 5d one place to check.
D11 Sprint plan moved from CLAUDE.md to sprint-plan.md, with a status column. Keeps CLAUDE.md short; the plan changes often and the rules do not.
D12 The Type A activity focuses on the lunar South Pole. The specific site or sites within it remain open. Ivaylo's decision. Consistent with the feasibility work done so far and with the data sets already explored.
D13 The production pipeline, data sets and tools described in CLAUDE.md are a baseline hypothesis from the RFI draft, not a fixed design. Research topics B and D must look for alternatives. Avoids research that only confirms the RFI design, and keeps the Type A scope open.
D14 Guide and call package distilled into pecs-playbook.md, compliance-matrix.md and evaluator-rubric.md. Where guide and call differ, the call is followed; differences are listed in playbook section 10. Order of authority (D7).
D15 Working target for the evaluator rounds: 70 or more overall and no criterion under 55. The threshold of 55 only makes a proposal eligible; proposals of all types share one budget and the national delegation selects from the ranking.
D16 ESA clarifications 1 to 9 are treated as part of the call documents and incorporated into the playbook (section 11), the compliance matrix (block K) and the rubric. They are official ESA answers.

Open (to be decided)

# Question Depends on
O1 Type A scope and what is out of scope Distillation, research
O2 End goal and deliverables. Boundary now known (F15): proof of concept of critical functions for one site, not an integrated validated system. Which functions, and what proves each, is open. Concept note
O3 Start and end TRL with evidence O1, O2
O4 Duration, price, work packages (fully funded is settled, F14) O1
O5 Team roles and time shares; whether an AI specialist is needed O1, research topic E
O6 How the Lithuanian customer is involved. Both routes are accepted by ESA (F24): a letter of interest in an annex, or a subcontract in a customer role, which needs its esa-star registration, its own signed PSS forms with non-zero cost (F25) and CVs. Negotiation; time left
O7 Whether any partner or adviser is critical O1
O8 Closed: see F3 and F16. —
O9 Which specific South Pole site or sites Research topics B and C (data coverage, user interest)
O10 AI disclosure text for the cover letter and section 2.4.3 Written at the end, from what was actually done
O11 Whether any existing Luminous work is declared as background IP Scope
O12 esa-star: check the entity data was updated in the last 12 months (cover letter point 4); decide whether to request the 35% advance; re-check the call page for new documents or clarifications before submission Ivaylo
O13 Partly closed: cloud processing for the activity is eligible in principle (F23). Still open: whether specific software licences count as activity-specific costs or as generic tools. Costing
O14 Remuneration arrangements for the activity: Ivaylo's rate as owner-manager, and Martin's engagement (employment or civil-law contract as direct labour, not an external service, if he manages a work package). ESA does not require these to be in place at submission; they must be lawful, described in the proposal, and actually applied during the contract. To be confirmed with the company's accountant. Also to check: Martin's university rules on outside work and IP. Ivaylo, accountant, Martin
O15 Start TRL to claim at system level (likely 1 or 2), with the evidence available today. Concept note

2026-11-14

Facts confirmed by Ivaylo

# Fact Source
F34 Bulgaria is a full EU Member State and has been in the euro area since 1 January 2026. Luminous Ltd costs and quotes in euro; the exchange rate on the PSS forms is 1. compliance-matrix.md row G3 and pecs-playbook.md section 6 previously said Bulgaria was outside the euro zone; both corrected. Ivaylo; Council Decision (EU) 2025/1407 of 8 July 2025, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dec/2025/1407/oj

Decisions

# Decision Reason
D17 Product direction is fixed: software for mission planning for lunar exploration, with a focus on the lunar South Pole. Everything else about the product may be challenged in a grilling session, to find the idea with the best unique proposition against competitors, feasibility with available data, fit to customer needs and fit to Type A (TRL 1 to 3). The session follows grilling-brief.md and produces concept-note.md. For that session D17 overrides CLAUDE.md section 2 and rule 10; CLAUDE.md is updated only after the result is confirmed. Ivaylo's decision, 14 November 2026. The SELIS description comes from the RFI draft and was not designed for Type A.