SELIS V2

Compliance matrix — SELIS V2

Built on 2026-11-13 from the call package in call-docs/ (ESA CfP/5-50197/26/NL/MH/cd). Every row is a requirement taken from a call document. Guide advice is not listed here; it is in pecs-playbook.md.

Sources: CL = ESA cover letter (001.eli), TC = tendering conditions (004.etc), TPL = cover letter and full proposal template (005.ept), DC = draft contract, fully funded (002.ecc), CQ n.m = ESA clarification n, question m (call-docs/clarifications/, numbers 1 to 9, read on 2026-11-13).

Status values: Open, Done, Decide (needs a decision by Ivaylo), N/A. Update the status as work proceeds. Before submission every row must be Done or N/A.

Clarifications 1 to 9 are included (block K). None of them changes the deadline, the limits or the criteria. Check esa-star again before submission for clarifications numbered 10 or higher: ESA can amend the call (TC 3.1).

A. Admissibility and Key Acceptance Factors

A failure in this block excludes the proposal from evaluation (TC 2.2).

ID Requirement Source Where met Status
A1 Tender loaded and submitted in esa-star not later than 26 November 2026, 13:00 Amsterdam time (14:00 in Sofia). CL 13 esa-star Open
A2 KAF 1: tenderer and any subcontractor satisfy the eligibility requirements (Contracting Regulations Article 12). CL 8, TC 1.1 Cover letter 18, esa-star Open
A3 KAF 2: free-competition statements hold (independent pricing, no disclosure, no restrictive exclusive teaming). CL 8, TPL cover letter 13 Cover letter 13 Open
A4 KAF 3: accept that ESA is not committed to place a contract. CL 8, TC 1.7 esa-star Open
A5 KAF 4: no benefit offered to any ESA official or evaluator. CL 8, TC 1.8 esa-star Open
A6 KAF 5: cover letter and full proposal contain a binding price. CL 8 Cover letter 5, section 3.1 Open
A7 KAF 6: price type is firm fixed price. CL 5, CL 8 Cover letter 5, section 3.1 Open
A8 KAF 7: price within the Type A limit of EUR 200,000. CL 4, CL 8 Cover letter 5, PSS A2 Open
A9 KAF 8: legal entity registered in Bulgaria. CL 8 Cover letter 1 Done (Luminous Ltd)
A10 KAF 9: accept the non-negotiable contract conditions, without reservation. CL 8, TPL cover letter 10 Cover letter 10 Open
A11 KAF 10: at most 2 proposals as prime and 3 in total (prime or subcontractor) per entity under this call. CL 9 esa-star Decide: confirm Luminous submits no more than this
A12 The proposal must not contradict any cover-letter declaration. TC 2.1, 2.2 Whole proposal Open

B. Registration and esa-star actions

ID Requirement Source Where met Status
B1 Prime registered in esa-star (light registration at least; full registration before contract). CL 7, CL 8e esa-star Done (registered and approved, per Ivaylo)
B2 Entity registration information updated within the last 12 months. TPL cover letter 4 esa-star Decide: check the date of the last update
B3 Every subcontractor has at least light registration at submission. CL 7, CL 8e esa-star N/A unless a subcontractor is added
B4 Notify interest to tender through the Expression of Interest function in esa-star Publication. CL 12 esa-star Done (13 November 2026, per Ivaylo)
B5 Consortium structure in esa-star mirrors the proposed team. CL 8f esa-star Open
B6 Declaration of Compliance and Key Acceptance Factors completed in esa-star Tendering. CL 8, TC 2 esa-star Open
B7 Clarification questions only through esa-star, at the latest 14 calendar days before closing (12 November 2026). CL 12 — N/A (window closed)
B8 Answer any ESA clarification request within 3 calendar days, through esa-star. CL 12 esa-star Open (after submission)
B9 Read ESA's fraud policy and inform personnel. CL 7 Internal Open
B10 No publicity about tendering before the result is notified. TC 1.3 Internal Open

C. Format and submission

ID Requirement Source Where met Status
C1 Proposal written in the template: same headings, subject matter, order and numbering; no change to font size, margins, line spacing or heading titles. CL 8, TPL note Proposal Open
C2 Remove all red captions and all ESA headers and footers before submission. CL 8, TPL note Proposal Open
C3 Proposal at most 25 pages, excluding cover letter, PSS forms and annexes. CL 8c, TC 4.1 Proposal Open
C4 Annexes are optional, are not marked, and only support statements made within the 25 pages. CL 8c Annexes Open
C5 Tender and all correspondence in English. CL 8 All Open
C6 Precise and concise; no mere repetition of ESA's requirements. CL 8 Proposal Open
C7 Document 1: the signed cover letter, as a separate file. CL 8d, CL 14 Cover letter Open
C8 Document 2: one single searchable, indexed PDF with the proposal, the signed PSS forms and any annexes. CL 8d, TPL note Proposal PDF Open
C9 CVs only in the dedicated CV folder in esa-star. TPL 2.2 esa-star Open (Ivaylo's CV present; Martin Ivanov's pending)
C10 PDF with no dynamic content, not encrypted, not password protected, at most 250 MB. TC Annex I Files Open
C11 Tender valid for 14 months from the closing date. CL 8b, TPL cover letter 16 Cover letter 16 Open
C12 Cover letter signed by the authorised representative. CL 14 Cover letter Open

D. Cover letter content

ID Requirement Source Status
D1 Title; resubmission yes or no; tenderer name; date; proposal reference number. TPL cover letter head Open
D2 Point 1: full name, address, telephone, nationality by ESA Convention criteria, VAT number, ESA entity code. TPL 1 Open
D3 Point 2, Table 1: legal nature, SME yes or no, entity code, business unit number, country, currency, price per entity, company contribution, total firm fixed price. TPL 2 Open: Luminous is registered as an SME in esa-star (per Ivaylo); enter YES
D4 Point 3: geographical distribution by country, for prime and subcontractors. TPL 3 Open
D5 Point 5: choose the fully funded option; state price without cents; state "Type A – Research and Preparatory Activities". TPL 5, CL 4 Open
D6 Point 6: contract duration in months (9 to 15). TPL 6, CL 4 Decide
D7 Points 7 and 8: contacts for the tender, technical matters, contractual matters, contract signatory, data-protection contact. TPL 7, 8 Open
D8 Point 9: certify technical and management compliance and freedom from plagiarism; quoted or cited material is marked and referenced. TPL 9 Open
D9 Point 9: choose one AI statement. Either none was used, or list the documents and proposal elements generated or substantially modified using AI. TPL 9, TC 4.2.1 Decide: list to be written at the end, from what was actually done
D10 Point 10: accept the draft contract; choose personal-data option A (only contact details and CVs) or B (personal data processed as part of the work). TPL 10 Decide: option A expected unless the scope processes personal data
D11 Point 11: declare background IP used (a) or none (b). TPL 11, DC 6.3 Decide
D12 Point 12: export-restriction statement (a) none or (b) list. TPL 12 Decide
D13 Point 14: continuation of an ESA contract, yes or no. TPL 14 Open (expected: not a continuation)
D14 Points 15 to 18: legal representative, validity, audit acknowledgement, KAF declaration, signature. TPL 15–18 Open

E. Proposal content, Part 1 — Technical and application

ID Section Requirement Source Status
E1 1.0 Background and need or opportunity; introduce the topic. TPL 1.0 Open
E2 1.1 Main objective or end goal. TPL 1.1 Open
E3 1.2 Key driving technical requirements and constraints; quantitative where possible; verification approach for each; justification, preferably with end-customer involvement. TPL 1.2 Open
E4 1.3 Start and end TRL with justification; compatible with Type A (start at least 1, end at most 3). TPL 1.3, CL 4 Decide
E5 1.4.1 State of the art: competitors, products and technologies in Europe and worldwide. TPL 1.4.1 Open
E6 1.4.2 Technical steps, consistent with the work logic and WBS. TPL 1.4.2 Open
E7 1.4.3 Work-logic flow chart with reviews, dependencies, iteration loops; consistent with steps, WBS and schedule. TPL 1.4.3 Open
E8 1.4.4 First iteration of the baseline concept; key trade-offs; how each step is performed and validated; consistent with the TRLs. TPL 1.4.4 Open
E9 1.5 Technical problem areas and risks in the given table (scenario, severity, likelihood, risk index, mitigation); alternatives for potential showstoppers. TPL 1.5 Open
E10 1.6.1 Justify compliance with the programmatic objectives and constraints of CL point 6 (see block I). TPL 1.6.1, CL 6 Open
E11 1.6.2 Business case: product or service, target customers, quantified and justified revenues, commercialisation plan, short- and medium-term benefits to the company, ESA and the European space sector. TPL 1.6.2 Open
E12 1.7.1 WBS for the whole activity: each work package with title and responsible entity; subcontracted work in its own work packages; prime's project management identified. TPL 1.7.1 Open
E13 1.7.2 One WPD per work package: company, start and end as T0+x, manager, tasks, outputs with identifiers that appear in the deliverables list; optional exclusions. TPL 1.7.2 Open
E14 1.7.2 A dedicated work package for management and reporting, covering meetings, progress reports and final documentation, and the management approach. TPL 1.7.2, DC Appendix 1 Open
E15 1.8 Company overview: personnel number, year established, sites, directly relevant experience only. TPL 1.8 Open
E16 1.9 Facilities and software tools needed, and how the right to use each is secured. TPL 1.9 Open
E17 1.10 Personal data processing section. TPL 1.10 N/A unless option B is chosen in D10
E18 All All work by non-Bulgarian entities highlighted, fully described and scoped. CL 2 N/A unless a non-Bulgarian entity is included
E19 All Non-Bulgarian subcontracts at most 20% of the total price, justified, and not core activity. CL 2 N/A unless a non-Bulgarian subcontractor is included

F. Proposal content, Part 2 — Management

ID Section Requirement Source Status
F1 2.1.1.1 Organigram: team composition, reporting lines, tasks, position, authority and names, including project manager and contracts officer; key and non-key personnel. TPL 2.1.1.1 Open
F2 2.1.1.2 Rationale for the split of work and for including or not including subcontractors. TPL 2.1.1.2 Open
F3 2.1.1.3 Time dedication table per key person; non-key hours stated outside the table; total hours equal to the PSS forms. TPL 2.1.1.3 Open
F4 2.2 Statement that CVs are provided separately in esa-star. TPL 2.2 Open
F5 2.3.1 Gantt chart from start to contract end with all work packages, meetings, milestones, dependencies and the critical path. TPL 2.3.1 Open
F6 2.3.2 Summary of planning assumptions. TPL 2.3.2 Open
F7 2.3.3 Meeting and travel table, consistent with PSS A2 Exhibit B; kick-off and final review by teleconference; Final Presentation at ESTEC; no public-relations, dissemination or seminar travel. TPL 2.3.3, DC Appendix 1 §1.4 Open
F8 2.4 Deliverables grouped into documentation, hardware and software, each described unambiguously. TPL 2.4 Open
F9 2.4.1 Mandatory deliverables included: Technical Data Package, Executive Summary (1 page), Final Report, Final Presentation, Contract Closure Documentation. TPL 2.4.1, DC Appendix 1 §1.5 Open
F10 2.4.1 Each proposed document has a bullet list of its main contents. TPL 2.4.1 Open
F11 2.4.2 For software: source or object code, delivery format, licences delivered to ESA. TPL 2.4 Open
F12 2.4.3 State whether any deliverable will be generated or substantially modified using AI systems. TPL 2.4.3, TC 4.2.2 Decide

G. Proposal content, Part 3 — Financial

ID Section Requirement Source Status
G1 3.1 Total firm fixed price in euro without cents, delivered duty paid, excluding VAT and import duties. TPL 3.1, DC 3 Open
G2 3.1 Royalties or licence fees identified and justified, if any. TPL 3.1a Open
G3 3.1 Currency: Bulgaria has been in the euro area since 1 January 2026, so the national currency on the PSS forms is EUR and the exchange rate is 1 EURO = 1. No conversion rate or hedging factor applies. Fill the currency and exchange-rate fields on PSS A2, Exhibit A, Exhibit B and PSS A8 consistently. A rate must be stated only for a purchase priced in another currency (Exhibit A) or for a subcontractor outside the euro area. TPL 3.1c; Council Decision (EU) 2025/1407 Open
G4 3.2.1 PSS A1, PSS A2, Exhibit A, Exhibit B and PSS A8 (issue 5) completed and signed, even if empty; PSS A8 in landscape. TPL 3.2.1, attachments Open
G5 3.2.1 Profit at most 8% of the base cost in PSS A2 item 9. TPL 3.2.1 Open
G6 3.2.1 Exhibit A detailed enough for independent checking. TPL 3.2.1 Open
G7 3.2.1 Each subcontractor fills in its own signed forms; the prime fills in its own and the total. TPL 3.2.1 N/A unless a subcontractor is added
G8 3.2.2 Milestone payment plan: progress and final payments only, summing to the price; each tied to a milestone with tangible deliverables. TPL 3.2.2, DC 4 Open
G9 3.2.2 Final payment at least 10% of the price, after any advance offset. TPL 3.2.2 Open
G10 3.2.2 Advance payment table. An SME is entitled to 35%. TPL 3.2.2 Decide: request the advance or not
G11 — No procurement of infrastructure or generic hardware or software tools in the costs. Infrastructure means assets that support general operations beyond the activity, including upgrades and depreciation. CL 6, CQ 2.1 Open

H. Proposal content, Part 4 — Contract conditions

ID Section Requirement Source Status
H1 4.1.1 Either the background and third-party IP table, or the statement that none is used. Must agree with cover letter point 11. TPL 4.1.1, DC 6.3 Decide
H2 4.1.2 Expected foreground IP. TPL 4.1.2 Open
H3 4.1.3 Two statements: the contractor owns the IP arising from the work (DC 6.2.1); ESA has an irrevocable right to use it for its own requirements (DC 6.2.2). TPL 4.1.3 Open
H4 4.1.3 Agreement on foreground IP with any subcontractor. TPL 4.1.3 N/A unless a subcontractor is added
H5 — IPR explicitly addressed; the activity should in principle lead to a product, application or service with national (Bulgarian) IPR. CL 6 Open

I. Programmatic objectives and constraints (to be shown in section 1.6.1)

ID Requirement Source Status
I1 Potential for further use or development in at least one of: ESA mandatory activities or optional programmes Bulgaria subscribes or intends to subscribe to; development of space capabilities, especially in industry; a niche market with no competing European product, or where a second source is an asset; long-term relations between national firms and space firms in ESA states; long-term relations between national firms and national universities and research institutions. CL 6 Open
I2 Take into account the special interests: cross-sectorial products or services; preparing Bulgaria's participation in ESA programmes; long-term competitiveness and benefit to national industry; economic growth or societal benefit within five years and sustainably after; key space competences in Bulgaria. CL 6 Open
I3 No duplication of ongoing or intended ESA activities, or of EU or other public programmes. Complementarity is allowed. CL 6 Open: depends on research topic A
I4 Type A aim: preparation for ESA optional programmes, or first steps of a recurring product or service for space, with potential use on future ESA or commercial missions. CL 4 Open
I5 End-customer inclusion is highly encouraged. A letter of interest in an annex is accepted and considered; a subcontract is encouraged but not required for Type A. CL 4, CQ 9.6 Decide: letter of interest or subcontract for the Lithuanian company

K. Requirements added or sharpened by ESA clarifications

ID Requirement Source Where met Status
K1 Substantiate a strong link to the space sector and relevance to future ESA or other missions, and the path beyond TRL 3 (mission, end users, business case or route to market, state of the art), in detail matching the maturity. CQ 9.2 1.0, 1.4.1, 1.6 Open
K2 State the start TRL at the level of the system being developed; justify it from component maturity and the degree of integration demonstrated. It must be reached at submission and evidenced. CQ 9.4, CQ 5.3 1.3 Open
K3 Activity-specific recurring costs such as cloud processing: report under PSS A2 items 3.1 to 3.7 or 3.10, and detail in Exhibit A. CQ 9.3 PSS A2, Exhibit A Open
K4 Owner-manager and other personnel costs: hours and rates shown and justified in the PSS forms; the person is actually paid by the company under a lawful arrangement; rates reflect cost actually borne. CQ 5.6, CQ 6.3, CQ 7.1 PSS A1, A2, A8 Decide: remuneration arrangement for each team member
K5 Economic conditions year on PSS A1 and A2: 2027 is acceptable for a 2027 start. CQ 6.4 PSS A1, A2 Open
K6 Identify all data sources and show the planned use is compatible with their terms of use. CQ 6.1 1.4.4, 1.9 Open: depends on research topic B
K7 Declare in the Part 4 table any pre-existing tool that is background IP and needed for the activity, even if not delivered. Separate background from foreground IP clearly. CQ 8.1, CQ 8.4, CQ 9.5 4.1.1, 4.1.2 Decide
K8 Letters of interest from prospective users go in an annex. CQ 9.6 Annex Open
K9 If an end customer is a subcontractor: its role, need, contribution to requirements and validation, and interest in using the result are substantiated; its costs are shown in its own PSS forms and cannot be zero; any waived amount goes on PSS A2 line 14; the subcontract follows DC Article 1.3.4. CQ 1.1, CQ 3.1, CQ 3.2, CQ 5.2 2.1.1.2, PSS forms N/A unless a subcontractor is added
K10 Do not name ESA staff as advisers and do not present any ESA statement as endorsement of the proposal. CQ 6.5 Whole proposal Open

J. Contract obligations to plan and cost for

These do not appear as proposal sections, but the work plan and price must cover them.

ID Obligation Source
J1 Nominated project manager responsible for management and execution. DC Appendix 1 §1.1
J2 Minutes of every meeting within 10 days. DC Appendix 1 §1.3.1
J3 Bar chart kept up to date and shown at every meeting. DC Appendix 1 §1.3.2
J4 Periodic progress reports (interval set in the contract). DC Appendix 1 §1.3.3
J5 Technical documents sent 2 weeks before the meeting that discusses them. DC Appendix 1 §1.3.5
J6 Kick-off and progress meetings by teleconference; final presentation at ESA premises, to a public audience, within 12 months of contract closure. DC Appendix 1 §1.4
J7 Final documents: finalised versions within 4 weeks of approval of the drafts. DC 2.3.1
J8 Payment only against achieved milestones, through esa-p; final settlement needs acceptance of all deliverables and signed Contract Closure Documentation. DC 4.1
J9 Transfer of IP arising from the work to an entity outside Bulgaria needs prior written authorisation of the Bulgarian government, requested through ESA, with a 5-week wait. DC 6.5
J10 ESA's Technical Officer verifies the TRL reached at the end. DC Appendix 4 §4.1