Compliance matrix — SELIS V2
Built on 2026-11-13 from the call package in call-docs/
(ESA CfP/5-50197/26/NL/MH/cd). Every row is a requirement taken from a
call document. Guide advice is not listed here; it is in
pecs-playbook.md.
Sources: CL = ESA cover letter (001.eli), TC = tendering
conditions (004.etc), TPL = cover letter and full proposal
template (005.ept), DC = draft contract, fully funded
(002.ecc), CQ n.m = ESA clarification n, question m
(call-docs/clarifications/, numbers 1 to 9, read on
2026-11-13).
Status values: Open, Done, Decide (needs a decision by Ivaylo), N/A. Update the status as work proceeds. Before submission every row must be Done or N/A.
Clarifications 1 to 9 are included (block K). None of them changes the deadline, the limits or the criteria. Check esa-star again before submission for clarifications numbered 10 or higher: ESA can amend the call (TC 3.1).
A. Admissibility and Key Acceptance Factors
A failure in this block excludes the proposal from evaluation (TC 2.2).
| ID | Requirement | Source | Where met | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Tender loaded and submitted in esa-star not later than 26 November 2026, 13:00 Amsterdam time (14:00 in Sofia). | CL 13 | esa-star | Open |
| A2 | KAF 1: tenderer and any subcontractor satisfy the eligibility requirements (Contracting Regulations Article 12). | CL 8, TC 1.1 | Cover letter 18, esa-star | Open |
| A3 | KAF 2: free-competition statements hold (independent pricing, no disclosure, no restrictive exclusive teaming). | CL 8, TPL cover letter 13 | Cover letter 13 | Open |
| A4 | KAF 3: accept that ESA is not committed to place a contract. | CL 8, TC 1.7 | esa-star | Open |
| A5 | KAF 4: no benefit offered to any ESA official or evaluator. | CL 8, TC 1.8 | esa-star | Open |
| A6 | KAF 5: cover letter and full proposal contain a binding price. | CL 8 | Cover letter 5, section 3.1 | Open |
| A7 | KAF 6: price type is firm fixed price. | CL 5, CL 8 | Cover letter 5, section 3.1 | Open |
| A8 | KAF 7: price within the Type A limit of EUR 200,000. | CL 4, CL 8 | Cover letter 5, PSS A2 | Open |
| A9 | KAF 8: legal entity registered in Bulgaria. | CL 8 | Cover letter 1 | Done (Luminous Ltd) |
| A10 | KAF 9: accept the non-negotiable contract conditions, without reservation. | CL 8, TPL cover letter 10 | Cover letter 10 | Open |
| A11 | KAF 10: at most 2 proposals as prime and 3 in total (prime or subcontractor) per entity under this call. | CL 9 | esa-star | Decide: confirm Luminous submits no more than this |
| A12 | The proposal must not contradict any cover-letter declaration. | TC 2.1, 2.2 | Whole proposal | Open |
B. Registration and esa-star actions
| ID | Requirement | Source | Where met | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B1 | Prime registered in esa-star (light registration at least; full registration before contract). | CL 7, CL 8e | esa-star | Done (registered and approved, per Ivaylo) |
| B2 | Entity registration information updated within the last 12 months. | TPL cover letter 4 | esa-star | Decide: check the date of the last update |
| B3 | Every subcontractor has at least light registration at submission. | CL 7, CL 8e | esa-star | N/A unless a subcontractor is added |
| B4 | Notify interest to tender through the Expression of Interest function in esa-star Publication. | CL 12 | esa-star | Done (13 November 2026, per Ivaylo) |
| B5 | Consortium structure in esa-star mirrors the proposed team. | CL 8f | esa-star | Open |
| B6 | Declaration of Compliance and Key Acceptance Factors completed in esa-star Tendering. | CL 8, TC 2 | esa-star | Open |
| B7 | Clarification questions only through esa-star, at the latest 14 calendar days before closing (12 November 2026). | CL 12 | — | N/A (window closed) |
| B8 | Answer any ESA clarification request within 3 calendar days, through esa-star. | CL 12 | esa-star | Open (after submission) |
| B9 | Read ESA's fraud policy and inform personnel. | CL 7 | Internal | Open |
| B10 | No publicity about tendering before the result is notified. | TC 1.3 | Internal | Open |
C. Format and submission
| ID | Requirement | Source | Where met | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | Proposal written in the template: same headings, subject matter, order and numbering; no change to font size, margins, line spacing or heading titles. | CL 8, TPL note | Proposal | Open |
| C2 | Remove all red captions and all ESA headers and footers before submission. | CL 8, TPL note | Proposal | Open |
| C3 | Proposal at most 25 pages, excluding cover letter, PSS forms and annexes. | CL 8c, TC 4.1 | Proposal | Open |
| C4 | Annexes are optional, are not marked, and only support statements made within the 25 pages. | CL 8c | Annexes | Open |
| C5 | Tender and all correspondence in English. | CL 8 | All | Open |
| C6 | Precise and concise; no mere repetition of ESA's requirements. | CL 8 | Proposal | Open |
| C7 | Document 1: the signed cover letter, as a separate file. | CL 8d, CL 14 | Cover letter | Open |
| C8 | Document 2: one single searchable, indexed PDF with the proposal, the signed PSS forms and any annexes. | CL 8d, TPL note | Proposal PDF | Open |
| C9 | CVs only in the dedicated CV folder in esa-star. | TPL 2.2 | esa-star | Open (Ivaylo's CV present; Martin Ivanov's pending) |
| C10 | PDF with no dynamic content, not encrypted, not password protected, at most 250 MB. | TC Annex I | Files | Open |
| C11 | Tender valid for 14 months from the closing date. | CL 8b, TPL cover letter 16 | Cover letter 16 | Open |
| C12 | Cover letter signed by the authorised representative. | CL 14 | Cover letter | Open |
D. Cover letter content
| ID | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Title; resubmission yes or no; tenderer name; date; proposal reference number. | TPL cover letter head | Open |
| D2 | Point 1: full name, address, telephone, nationality by ESA Convention criteria, VAT number, ESA entity code. | TPL 1 | Open |
| D3 | Point 2, Table 1: legal nature, SME yes or no, entity code, business unit number, country, currency, price per entity, company contribution, total firm fixed price. | TPL 2 | Open: Luminous is registered as an SME in esa-star (per Ivaylo); enter YES |
| D4 | Point 3: geographical distribution by country, for prime and subcontractors. | TPL 3 | Open |
| D5 | Point 5: choose the fully funded option; state price without cents; state "Type A – Research and Preparatory Activities". | TPL 5, CL 4 | Open |
| D6 | Point 6: contract duration in months (9 to 15). | TPL 6, CL 4 | Decide |
| D7 | Points 7 and 8: contacts for the tender, technical matters, contractual matters, contract signatory, data-protection contact. | TPL 7, 8 | Open |
| D8 | Point 9: certify technical and management compliance and freedom from plagiarism; quoted or cited material is marked and referenced. | TPL 9 | Open |
| D9 | Point 9: choose one AI statement. Either none was used, or list the documents and proposal elements generated or substantially modified using AI. | TPL 9, TC 4.2.1 | Decide: list to be written at the end, from what was actually done |
| D10 | Point 10: accept the draft contract; choose personal-data option A (only contact details and CVs) or B (personal data processed as part of the work). | TPL 10 | Decide: option A expected unless the scope processes personal data |
| D11 | Point 11: declare background IP used (a) or none (b). | TPL 11, DC 6.3 | Decide |
| D12 | Point 12: export-restriction statement (a) none or (b) list. | TPL 12 | Decide |
| D13 | Point 14: continuation of an ESA contract, yes or no. | TPL 14 | Open (expected: not a continuation) |
| D14 | Points 15 to 18: legal representative, validity, audit acknowledgement, KAF declaration, signature. | TPL 15–18 | Open |
E. Proposal content, Part 1 — Technical and application
| ID | Section | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | 1.0 | Background and need or opportunity; introduce the topic. | TPL 1.0 | Open |
| E2 | 1.1 | Main objective or end goal. | TPL 1.1 | Open |
| E3 | 1.2 | Key driving technical requirements and constraints; quantitative where possible; verification approach for each; justification, preferably with end-customer involvement. | TPL 1.2 | Open |
| E4 | 1.3 | Start and end TRL with justification; compatible with Type A (start at least 1, end at most 3). | TPL 1.3, CL 4 | Decide |
| E5 | 1.4.1 | State of the art: competitors, products and technologies in Europe and worldwide. | TPL 1.4.1 | Open |
| E6 | 1.4.2 | Technical steps, consistent with the work logic and WBS. | TPL 1.4.2 | Open |
| E7 | 1.4.3 | Work-logic flow chart with reviews, dependencies, iteration loops; consistent with steps, WBS and schedule. | TPL 1.4.3 | Open |
| E8 | 1.4.4 | First iteration of the baseline concept; key trade-offs; how each step is performed and validated; consistent with the TRLs. | TPL 1.4.4 | Open |
| E9 | 1.5 | Technical problem areas and risks in the given table (scenario, severity, likelihood, risk index, mitigation); alternatives for potential showstoppers. | TPL 1.5 | Open |
| E10 | 1.6.1 | Justify compliance with the programmatic objectives and constraints of CL point 6 (see block I). | TPL 1.6.1, CL 6 | Open |
| E11 | 1.6.2 | Business case: product or service, target customers, quantified and justified revenues, commercialisation plan, short- and medium-term benefits to the company, ESA and the European space sector. | TPL 1.6.2 | Open |
| E12 | 1.7.1 | WBS for the whole activity: each work package with title and responsible entity; subcontracted work in its own work packages; prime's project management identified. | TPL 1.7.1 | Open |
| E13 | 1.7.2 | One WPD per work package: company, start and end as T0+x, manager, tasks, outputs with identifiers that appear in the deliverables list; optional exclusions. | TPL 1.7.2 | Open |
| E14 | 1.7.2 | A dedicated work package for management and reporting, covering meetings, progress reports and final documentation, and the management approach. | TPL 1.7.2, DC Appendix 1 | Open |
| E15 | 1.8 | Company overview: personnel number, year established, sites, directly relevant experience only. | TPL 1.8 | Open |
| E16 | 1.9 | Facilities and software tools needed, and how the right to use each is secured. | TPL 1.9 | Open |
| E17 | 1.10 | Personal data processing section. | TPL 1.10 | N/A unless option B is chosen in D10 |
| E18 | All | All work by non-Bulgarian entities highlighted, fully described and scoped. | CL 2 | N/A unless a non-Bulgarian entity is included |
| E19 | All | Non-Bulgarian subcontracts at most 20% of the total price, justified, and not core activity. | CL 2 | N/A unless a non-Bulgarian subcontractor is included |
F. Proposal content, Part 2 — Management
| ID | Section | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | 2.1.1.1 | Organigram: team composition, reporting lines, tasks, position, authority and names, including project manager and contracts officer; key and non-key personnel. | TPL 2.1.1.1 | Open |
| F2 | 2.1.1.2 | Rationale for the split of work and for including or not including subcontractors. | TPL 2.1.1.2 | Open |
| F3 | 2.1.1.3 | Time dedication table per key person; non-key hours stated outside the table; total hours equal to the PSS forms. | TPL 2.1.1.3 | Open |
| F4 | 2.2 | Statement that CVs are provided separately in esa-star. | TPL 2.2 | Open |
| F5 | 2.3.1 | Gantt chart from start to contract end with all work packages, meetings, milestones, dependencies and the critical path. | TPL 2.3.1 | Open |
| F6 | 2.3.2 | Summary of planning assumptions. | TPL 2.3.2 | Open |
| F7 | 2.3.3 | Meeting and travel table, consistent with PSS A2 Exhibit B; kick-off and final review by teleconference; Final Presentation at ESTEC; no public-relations, dissemination or seminar travel. | TPL 2.3.3, DC Appendix 1 §1.4 | Open |
| F8 | 2.4 | Deliverables grouped into documentation, hardware and software, each described unambiguously. | TPL 2.4 | Open |
| F9 | 2.4.1 | Mandatory deliverables included: Technical Data Package, Executive Summary (1 page), Final Report, Final Presentation, Contract Closure Documentation. | TPL 2.4.1, DC Appendix 1 §1.5 | Open |
| F10 | 2.4.1 | Each proposed document has a bullet list of its main contents. | TPL 2.4.1 | Open |
| F11 | 2.4.2 | For software: source or object code, delivery format, licences delivered to ESA. | TPL 2.4 | Open |
| F12 | 2.4.3 | State whether any deliverable will be generated or substantially modified using AI systems. | TPL 2.4.3, TC 4.2.2 | Decide |
G. Proposal content, Part 3 — Financial
| ID | Section | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1 | 3.1 | Total firm fixed price in euro without cents, delivered duty paid, excluding VAT and import duties. | TPL 3.1, DC 3 | Open |
| G2 | 3.1 | Royalties or licence fees identified and justified, if any. | TPL 3.1a | Open |
| G3 | 3.1 | Currency: Bulgaria has been in the euro area since 1 January 2026, so the national currency on the PSS forms is EUR and the exchange rate is 1 EURO = 1. No conversion rate or hedging factor applies. Fill the currency and exchange-rate fields on PSS A2, Exhibit A, Exhibit B and PSS A8 consistently. A rate must be stated only for a purchase priced in another currency (Exhibit A) or for a subcontractor outside the euro area. | TPL 3.1c; Council Decision (EU) 2025/1407 | Open |
| G4 | 3.2.1 | PSS A1, PSS A2, Exhibit A, Exhibit B and PSS A8 (issue 5) completed and signed, even if empty; PSS A8 in landscape. | TPL 3.2.1, attachments | Open |
| G5 | 3.2.1 | Profit at most 8% of the base cost in PSS A2 item 9. | TPL 3.2.1 | Open |
| G6 | 3.2.1 | Exhibit A detailed enough for independent checking. | TPL 3.2.1 | Open |
| G7 | 3.2.1 | Each subcontractor fills in its own signed forms; the prime fills in its own and the total. | TPL 3.2.1 | N/A unless a subcontractor is added |
| G8 | 3.2.2 | Milestone payment plan: progress and final payments only, summing to the price; each tied to a milestone with tangible deliverables. | TPL 3.2.2, DC 4 | Open |
| G9 | 3.2.2 | Final payment at least 10% of the price, after any advance offset. | TPL 3.2.2 | Open |
| G10 | 3.2.2 | Advance payment table. An SME is entitled to 35%. | TPL 3.2.2 | Decide: request the advance or not |
| G11 | — | No procurement of infrastructure or generic hardware or software tools in the costs. Infrastructure means assets that support general operations beyond the activity, including upgrades and depreciation. | CL 6, CQ 2.1 | Open |
H. Proposal content, Part 4 — Contract conditions
| ID | Section | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| H1 | 4.1.1 | Either the background and third-party IP table, or the statement that none is used. Must agree with cover letter point 11. | TPL 4.1.1, DC 6.3 | Decide |
| H2 | 4.1.2 | Expected foreground IP. | TPL 4.1.2 | Open |
| H3 | 4.1.3 | Two statements: the contractor owns the IP arising from the work (DC 6.2.1); ESA has an irrevocable right to use it for its own requirements (DC 6.2.2). | TPL 4.1.3 | Open |
| H4 | 4.1.3 | Agreement on foreground IP with any subcontractor. | TPL 4.1.3 | N/A unless a subcontractor is added |
| H5 | — | IPR explicitly addressed; the activity should in principle lead to a product, application or service with national (Bulgarian) IPR. | CL 6 | Open |
I. Programmatic objectives and constraints (to be shown in section 1.6.1)
| ID | Requirement | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| I1 | Potential for further use or development in at least one of: ESA mandatory activities or optional programmes Bulgaria subscribes or intends to subscribe to; development of space capabilities, especially in industry; a niche market with no competing European product, or where a second source is an asset; long-term relations between national firms and space firms in ESA states; long-term relations between national firms and national universities and research institutions. | CL 6 | Open |
| I2 | Take into account the special interests: cross-sectorial products or services; preparing Bulgaria's participation in ESA programmes; long-term competitiveness and benefit to national industry; economic growth or societal benefit within five years and sustainably after; key space competences in Bulgaria. | CL 6 | Open |
| I3 | No duplication of ongoing or intended ESA activities, or of EU or other public programmes. Complementarity is allowed. | CL 6 | Open: depends on research topic A |
| I4 | Type A aim: preparation for ESA optional programmes, or first steps of a recurring product or service for space, with potential use on future ESA or commercial missions. | CL 4 | Open |
| I5 | End-customer inclusion is highly encouraged. A letter of interest in an annex is accepted and considered; a subcontract is encouraged but not required for Type A. | CL 4, CQ 9.6 | Decide: letter of interest or subcontract for the Lithuanian company |
K. Requirements added or sharpened by ESA clarifications
| ID | Requirement | Source | Where met | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| K1 | Substantiate a strong link to the space sector and relevance to future ESA or other missions, and the path beyond TRL 3 (mission, end users, business case or route to market, state of the art), in detail matching the maturity. | CQ 9.2 | 1.0, 1.4.1, 1.6 | Open |
| K2 | State the start TRL at the level of the system being developed; justify it from component maturity and the degree of integration demonstrated. It must be reached at submission and evidenced. | CQ 9.4, CQ 5.3 | 1.3 | Open |
| K3 | Activity-specific recurring costs such as cloud processing: report under PSS A2 items 3.1 to 3.7 or 3.10, and detail in Exhibit A. | CQ 9.3 | PSS A2, Exhibit A | Open |
| K4 | Owner-manager and other personnel costs: hours and rates shown and justified in the PSS forms; the person is actually paid by the company under a lawful arrangement; rates reflect cost actually borne. | CQ 5.6, CQ 6.3, CQ 7.1 | PSS A1, A2, A8 | Decide: remuneration arrangement for each team member |
| K5 | Economic conditions year on PSS A1 and A2: 2027 is acceptable for a 2027 start. | CQ 6.4 | PSS A1, A2 | Open |
| K6 | Identify all data sources and show the planned use is compatible with their terms of use. | CQ 6.1 | 1.4.4, 1.9 | Open: depends on research topic B |
| K7 | Declare in the Part 4 table any pre-existing tool that is background IP and needed for the activity, even if not delivered. Separate background from foreground IP clearly. | CQ 8.1, CQ 8.4, CQ 9.5 | 4.1.1, 4.1.2 | Decide |
| K8 | Letters of interest from prospective users go in an annex. | CQ 9.6 | Annex | Open |
| K9 | If an end customer is a subcontractor: its role, need, contribution to requirements and validation, and interest in using the result are substantiated; its costs are shown in its own PSS forms and cannot be zero; any waived amount goes on PSS A2 line 14; the subcontract follows DC Article 1.3.4. | CQ 1.1, CQ 3.1, CQ 3.2, CQ 5.2 | 2.1.1.2, PSS forms | N/A unless a subcontractor is added |
| K10 | Do not name ESA staff as advisers and do not present any ESA statement as endorsement of the proposal. | CQ 6.5 | Whole proposal | Open |
J. Contract obligations to plan and cost for
These do not appear as proposal sections, but the work plan and price must cover them.
| ID | Obligation | Source |
|---|---|---|
| J1 | Nominated project manager responsible for management and execution. | DC Appendix 1 §1.1 |
| J2 | Minutes of every meeting within 10 days. | DC Appendix 1 §1.3.1 |
| J3 | Bar chart kept up to date and shown at every meeting. | DC Appendix 1 §1.3.2 |
| J4 | Periodic progress reports (interval set in the contract). | DC Appendix 1 §1.3.3 |
| J5 | Technical documents sent 2 weeks before the meeting that discusses them. | DC Appendix 1 §1.3.5 |
| J6 | Kick-off and progress meetings by teleconference; final presentation at ESA premises, to a public audience, within 12 months of contract closure. | DC Appendix 1 §1.4 |
| J7 | Final documents: finalised versions within 4 weeks of approval of the drafts. | DC 2.3.1 |
| J8 | Payment only against achieved milestones, through esa-p; final settlement needs acceptance of all deliverables and signed Contract Closure Documentation. | DC 4.1 |
| J9 | Transfer of IP arising from the work to an entity outside Bulgaria needs prior written authorisation of the Bulgarian government, requested through ESA, with a 5-week wait. | DC 6.5 |
| J10 | ESA's Technical Officer verifies the TRL reached at the end. | DC Appendix 4 §4.1 |