Goal
Find the best product idea for the PECS Type A proposal. The current SELIS description is one candidate, not the answer. The session ends when Ivaylo picks one product idea. Details (work packages, cost, feasibility research) come later, in other sessions.
Fixed
- Direction: software for mission planning for lunar exploration, with a focus on the lunar South Pole (decision D17).
- Applicant: Luminous Ltd.
- No invented facts. Inferred or synthetic output is never described as measured.
Everything else is open: user, product form, functions, data, site, name.
Read first
research/findings/A-competitors.md: what already exists.research/findings/A2-competitors.md: what already exists.research/findings/B-data-sets.md: what the data supports and rules out.research/findings/C-users-and-needs.md: who needs what.pecs-playbook.mdsections 1, 3 and 11: what a Type A activity must be.CLAUDE.md: the current idea, the current state of work and the team.
Four tests
A product idea must pass all four. Give the file and section for each verdict.
- Unique. It does something the tools in findings A do not. It does not duplicate an ESA activity. Non-EU competitors are not treated as direct competitors because the final idea can bring similar capabilities in the European market.
- Feasible. The data in findings B supports it, and measured data exists to check the result.
- Needed. A user group in findings C makes a planning decision better with it.
- Fits PECS Type A. TRL 1 to 3: a proof of concept of the critical functions, not an integrated system. At most EUR 200,000 and 9 to 15 months. No generic hardware. A clear path to an ESA or commercial mission.
Method
- State the three strongest objections to the current SELIS idea, from the findings.
- Propose three to five product ideas inside the fixed direction. If needed change or modify some of the existing features to align them with the tests.
- Score each idea against the four tests in one table: pass, weak or fail.
- Grill Ivaylo on the ideas that survive. Give a recommended answer for each question, with its source file or the word "judgement". Look facts up in the repository; ask Ivaylo only for decisions and for what only he knows.
- Where the research has no answer, say so. Do not guess.