SELIS competitors: summary
18 November 2026. Condensed from
research/topics/A-competitors.md,
research/topics/A2-competitors.md,
research/findings/A-competitors.md and
research/findings/A2-competitors.md (sources read 13 and 14
November 2026). One point in the conclusion also uses
research/findings/A3-uncertainty-in-planning.md, because it
corrects a claim made in A2. Every row traces to the "Ref" column; links
and dates are in section 8 of those files. "Unknown" means searched and
not found. "Judgement" marks an assessment. Compiled with AI (Claude);
not yet re-checked by a person.
Overview
About 20 lunar digital-twin, site-analysis and simulation products were reviewed. None combines everything a mission team needs to plan infrastructure at a South Pole site in one tool that a European company can buy. The functions themselves (terrain, illumination, Earth visibility, slope and hazard maps, 3D scenes, route planning) all exist somewhere. The most complete tools are American and either kept in-house (Voyager's DEMkit and LunaRay) or offered free by NASA (Moon Trek, QuickMap, DUST). The European activities are research projects, in-house prototypes or proposals: CNES Spaceship FR, the ESA-funded Milrem and Tartu planning system, ADTLAS, and the Dutch-German "Digital Twin of the Moon" initiative. No reviewed product states an uncertainty on its planning results.
Ranked comparison
Ranking rule: how close the product is today to a usable site-level planning tool for lunar infrastructure. The rank weighs three things: functions shown in the sources (not only claimed), maturity or use in a real mission, and access for an outside customer. It is not a quality score, and ranks 4 to 8 are close. "EU market" means evidence that a customer in the EU can obtain the product. "ESA link" means funding by ESA, an ESA contract or ESA membership of the project.
| Rank | Product; owner, country | What it is; maturity | Strengths | Weaknesses | EU market | ESA link | Ref |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | DEMkit and LunaRay; Astrobotic, now Voyager Technologies, US | Terrain and lighting tool suite; used to select the Griffin-1 landing site (2026) | Widest demonstrated function set: DEM generation and alignment, lighting validated against orbiter images, Earth-station and relay visibility, landing cost maps, rover paths, synthetic rocks and craters. Used in a real mission. | In-house tool of a lander company; no public product, price or named external customer. No output uncertainty described. | Not found | None found | A2 3.1 item 15 |
| 2 | Moon Trek (NASA JPL) and QuickMap (ASU and ACT); US | Free web portals; operational for years | Many co-registered layers; lighting, slope, line-of-sight and traverse tools. NASA reports use by CLPS providers for site characterisation. Free. ACT sells QuickMap team deployments. | Fixed tool set in a portal; no per-cell provenance or uncertainty in outputs (judgement). LROC operations moved to Intuitive Machines in May 2026; future terms unknown. | Free web access works from the EU; paid deployments in the EU: not found | None found. Moon Trek hosts UCL DEMs that ESA also archives. | A2 3.1 items 9, 10 |
| 3 | DUST; NASA JSC, US | 3D South Pole visualisation, version 1.9 | 3D scene with Sun and Earth geometry, slope maps, traverse view; 5 m terrain plus 20 cm synthetic detail. Free. | NASA calls it an early reference for vendors' initial studies. No analysis outputs with uncertainty. Synthetic detail mixed into the scene. | Through a NASA Software User Agreement; eligibility of non-US companies unknown | None found | A2 3.1 item 8 |
| 4 | Spaceship FR digital twin of the Moon; CNES, FR | In-house prototype; first mock-up, roadmap being defined (2025) | Planning is the stated purpose: polar terrain at 5 m, illumination over 1 to 10 years, illuminated rover paths, habitat siting used to size a power system. | No validation against measured data, no uncertainty, no Earth-visibility result. Temperature, communications and radiation layers are a concept. | No (internal to CNES) | Part of the ESA-coordinated Spaceship network; ESA co-funds staff | A 3, A2 3.1 item 2 |
| 5 | Mission-planning system and ULYSSES simulator; Milrem Robotics and Tartu Observatory, EE | ESA contract signed 2021; results 2022; thesis prototype 2024 | Automatic planning of points of interest and routes over hundreds of km²; time-dependent shadows in the route solver; simulator with Sun, shadows, solar power, battery and Earth-visibility windows. | Built for rover traverses, not fixed infrastructure (judgement). Shown on the Apollo 15 site, not the South Pole. Status after 2024, licence and availability unknown. | Not found | ESA contract "Operations and mobility planning system for Lunar rover missions" | A2 3.1 item 19 |
| 6 | MoonHacker and RADSIM; Lunar Station Corp, US | Commercial offer; access by briefing or demo | Claims the widest scope: site selection, terrain analytics, site and route comparison, thermal and radiation modelling. NASA Spinoff coverage. | Nothing verifiable: no method, data sources, validation, customers or prices published. Rank is uncertain. | Not found | None found | A2 3.1 item 14 |
| 7 | PANGU (University of Dundee, STAR-Dundee, UK); also SurRender (Airbus, FR) | Sensor-image simulators; PANGU v7 (2023) | Camera, lidar, radar and thermal-infrared simulation on imported DEMs; SPICE geometry; South Pole landing demonstrated. | Built for navigation testing; no time-series illumination or visibility maps and no site analysis. PANGU validation in 2019 was visual only. | PANGU licences sold; UK is in ESA, not in the EU | PANGU developed with ESA support and free for ESA projects; SurRender: not checked | A 3, A2 3.1 item 5 |
| 8 | Digital Twin of the Moon; TU Delft, DLR, Airbus Defence and Space, TerraSigna, SCN Avatar, ATG Europe; NL and DE | Initiative; no tool yet; first version hoped for 2026 or 2027, target 2030 | Widest European ambition: one multi-scale model and data repository; mission design, training and synthetic data as uses. Members include an agency, a prime and a university. | Twin itself not funded; members build parts separately. No data sources, site, resolution, functions, validation or licence stated. | No product yet | ESA named as a stakeholder; ESA funding not found | A2 3.1 item 22 |
| 9 | Cesium Moon Terrain; Cesium (Bentley Systems), US. Used with Synopsys and Keysight tools in NASA Glenn's lunar radio model ("Lunar 3GPP") | Global 3D terrain tiles, released 2024 | Ready 3D base layer with Unreal Engine and Unity plug-ins; polar terrain at 5 m. The NASA radio model finds radio shadow zones and supports antenna placement. | Base layer only: no illumination, thermal or hazard analysis, no uncertainty. The radio tools are separate commercial US software. | Yes: online account; free for non-commercial use, paid for commercial use | None found | A2 3.1 item 16 |
| 10 | ADTLAS (Fraunhofer FIT with ESA and five companies, DE); also ESA XR Lab (LUNA-XR, VR South Pole) | Research activity, running 2025 to 2027 per ESA record; XR Lab in-house | Direct ESA involvement; 3D models of the lunar environment and surface systems; tied to the LUNA analogue facility and astronaut user studies. | XR, human interaction and IT infrastructure; no illumination, visibility, hazard or planning function stated. Closed consortium. | No | ESA OSIP activity; ESA is a consortium member. XR Lab is ESA's own. | A 3, A2 3.1 item 1 |
| 11 | Lunar digital twin; ispace and SpaceData, JP | Collaboration agreement, March 2025 | Terrain with physics simulation, built from ispace mission data. | Not yet a product; scope and access not stated. | Not found | None found | A 3 |
| 12 | OmniLRS; University of Luxembourg and Tohoku University (LU, JP) | Open-source robotics simulator, 2023 | Synthetic sensor data for robotics; open source. | Procedural terrain, not tied to a measured site; no planning layers. | Yes (open source) | Not found | A 3 |
| – | SELIS; Luminous Ltd, BG (for reference, not ranked) | Idea stage; preliminary feasibility only | Design rule of per-cell provenance and confidence across measured, derived, inferred and synthetic data; South Pole focus; can reuse the open data and tools listed below. | Nothing integrated yet: DEMs from stereo pairs to test tooling and photovoltaic demonstrations only. No users, no mission use, no validation. Small team. | Not yet | None (the 2026 RFI answer is not ESA interest) | CLAUDE.md section 2 |
Also reviewed, not ranked because they are components, data, methods or closed projects: five ESA OSIP projects from the 2023 campaign (DEM, topography, rendering and synthetic-data tools; contractors unknown); NASA PGDA terrain with uncertainty; NASA LuNaMaps tools; JAXA LUPEX terrain; UCL MADNet and TU Berlin/DLR deep-learning DEMs; NASA IllumNG; Project Chrono; LandSAfe (ESA, 2012); EXPLORE L-Hex (EU Horizon 2020, ended 2023, code not found); ALTEC lunar simulation centre (ASI); Moonraker lidar mission (ESA, launch 2030). See A2 section 3.2 and A section 3.
Conclusion: where SELIS can fit as a PECS Type A activity
The evidence does not support "lunar digital twin" or "mission-planning software for the South Pole" as a novelty claim. Products ranked 1 to 5 already cover these functions, and two European activities with ESA links (Spaceship FR, Milrem and Tartu) plus a European consortium (Digital Twin of the Moon) use the same words. An evaluator who knows them will down-mark a proposal that does not name them. The functions are also not where the competitors are weakest.
Where they are weakest in the sources read is trust in the result.
None of the ranked tools states how certain its illumination, visibility
or siting outputs are, or separates measured from inferred and synthetic
terrain in its outputs. A3-uncertainty-in-planning.md
narrows this gap. NASA published the method for illumination in 2021,
with 100 terrain clones at four South Pole sites. ESA's 2012 Lunar
Lander study named confidence levels as a requirement. So the method is
not new. What was not found is a tool or service that delivers such
results to a user, the same treatment for Earth visibility at the pole,
or a check of a stated uncertainty against dated images.
A Type A activity (TRL at most 3, at most EUR 200,000, 9 to 15 months) can therefore fit as a proof of concept on one South Pole site. It would produce a few planning layers (for example illumination and power, Earth visibility, slope and hazard) with a per-cell data class and an uncertainty carried through to the result, checked against measured data. It would reuse open data and tools (PGDA, JAXA terrain, Ames Stereo Pipeline, published illumination methods) rather than rebuild them. It would leave XR and training, rover route optimisation, new DEM methods and sensor-image simulation to the activities that already do them. It would present SELIS as a possible supplier of traceable site data to Spaceship FR, ADTLAS, the Digital Twin of the Moon initiative and the Milrem and Tartu work, not as their rival.
Two limits apply to this fit (judgement). First, SELIS starts behind every ranked product: it has no working pipeline, no user and no mission use, and the narrowed claim is a research question whose outcome is open. Second, this review shows a gap in supply, not proof of demand. Whether users will pay for uncertainty-aware results over free NASA tools is a question for topic C, not answered here.