Idea 3 — Surface activity interference assessment
15 November 2026. One of six ideas; read 00-overview.md
first. Source numbers refer to its section 8. Compiled with AI (Claude);
not re-checked by a person. "Judgement" marks an assessment.
Product in one line
For a planned landing or surface operation (place, time window, lander mass class, mast heights, emitters), the tool returns the zones in which it affects registered neighbours: plume disturbance and ejecta reach, dust deposition, shadow cast on solar arrays, and blocked LoS for radio and optical links. It also produces a notification data set.
Decision it supports
An operator chooses a landing point and time that do not harm a neighbour, and shows this to its authorising state. An authority or registry checks a declared activity against others.
Why now
- Activity concentrates. NASA builds its Moon Base at the South Pole with eight lander companies under CLPS 2 [1]. Open Lunar Foundation expects near- and medium-term activity in fewer than ten sites of about 35 km by 70 km [19].
- The same article cites modelling in which an installation 5 km from a ten-tonne lander has a 37% chance of being struck by ejecta [19]. The underlying study was not opened.
- ATLAC works on a possible international mechanism for information sharing and consultation; its co-chairs list fragmented information sharing as a gap [16]. A commentary expects the final report in 2027 [17].
- The International Telecommunication Union had received more than 50 lunar spectrum filings by 2025 [18].
- NASA plans to feed its plume test data into data-driven models that predict erosion and ejecta for large landers and nearby surface assets [22]. The DISCO payload will study how rocket exhaust disturbs the ground [2].
What exists
- Registries: the Lunar Ledger of Open Lunar Foundation records objects and activities. The article read describes declarations; it does not describe computed interference [19].
- One illustrative plume-effects map by Open Lunar, made with Moon Trek and a published model [19].
- Plume physics: ESA's LUNAR ISLANDS activity (F section 2) and NASA's test programme [22]. This idea uses their published results and does not simulate plumes.
- A planning tool that computes effects between neighbouring assets: not found (two searches).
Data basis and checks
- Measured: areas of changed reflectance around Apollo, Luna, Surveyor and Chang'e-3 landers in LROC images; the area grows with lander mass and thrust, from hundreds of square metres for Surveyor to tens of thousands for Apollo [20]. Chang'e-3: about 2,530 m² [20].
- Measured: stereo images of the Blue Ghost landing in March 2025, the first dedicated in-situ PSI measurements [21].
- Not measured: ejecta at kilometre range. Output for that range is inferred and must be labelled so.
- Shadow and LoS between assets are derived from LOLA terrain (B finding 1).
Type A slice (TRL 3)
| CF | Function | Check |
|---|---|---|
| CF1 | Near-field disturbance zone from lander mass class | Predicted area against measured areas at four or more historic landing sites |
| CF2 | Shadow and LoS effects between two assets on South Pole terrain | Predicted shadow against dated NAC images, as in A3 section 3.2 |
| CF3 | Far-field ejecta envelope from published models, as a range | No measured check exists. Fallback: report the published range and its source only |
| CF4 | Notification data set that maps to registry fields | Round trip with the Lunar Ledger field list [TBD: access to the field list] |
Out of the Type A slice: radio interference levels, scheduling of several activities, a hosted service, legal assessment.
Users outside ESA (candidates; none contacted)
- Operators: the CLPS 2 companies, ispace, Space Applications Services.
- Public bodies: national authorities that license lunar missions [TBD which; not researched]; ATLAC participants.
- Registry operators: Open Lunar Foundation, more likely a partner than a customer.
- Insurers: not researched.
Four tests (judgement)
- Unique: pass. Registries exist; an analysis tool was not found.
- Feasible: weak. Near field, shadow and LoS can be checked; far-field ejecta cannot.
- Needed: weak. The policy need is documented. No source shows an operator or authority that would pay.
- Fits Type A: pass. Four critical functions at the upper limit; drop CF4 if effort is short.
Link to ESA programmes and path beyond TRL 3
Argonaut will land in a region that other landers also target (C finding 3). Results of LUNAR ISLANDS are inputs, which makes this a complement and not a duplicate, if stated in section 1.6.1. Next step: adoption of the notification data set by a registry or an authority.
Risks and unknowns
- Operators may not want to disclose landing plans. The tool must work with partial data.
- Plume and ejecta expertise is not shown in the CV on file. The idea is only credible if it reuses published scaling laws and says so.
- A follow-on to LUNAR ISLANDS, or an ESA activity on safety zones: not checked.
- The topic is political. An evaluator may see it as policy work, not as technology at TRL 1 to 3.