SELIS V2 / research / findings

Topic B — Data sets: findings

13 November 2026; all sources opened that day. Bracketed numbers refer to section 8. "(extract)" in section 8 marks a source read as a search extract of the page, not the full page. "Judgement" marks an assessment, not a sourced fact. "Not found" means searched and not found. Compiled with AI (Claude); sources not yet re-checked by a person. Corrected on 15 November 2026 from B2-site-data-coverage.md, with AI (Claude); the corrections are not yet re-checked by a person.

1. Feeds

1.2 Requirements; 1.4.4 Implementation aspects; 1.5 Technical Problem Areas and Risks; 1.9 Facilities.

2. Key findings

  1. LOLA is the terrain backbone at the South Pole, and most of it is interpolated. NASA publishes 5 m/pixel LOLA DEMs with count, height-uncertainty and slope-uncertainty maps and 100 statistical clones for more than 25 named sites, plus a 5 m mosaic around the pole [5][8]. At 5 m about 10% of pixels hold a LOLA return; the rest are interpolated [6]. Typical RMS uncertainty: 0.3 to 0.5 m in height, 1.5 to 2.5° in slope [6].
  2. NAC stereo is not the main terrain method at the pole; shape-from-shading (SfS) is the method in use. The PDS holds 11 NAC stereo DTMs poleward of 83.4°S (count from a PDS Orbital Data Explorer query in B2-site-data-coverage.md, not a published figure) [35]. DLR made three at 2 m for the ESA Lunar Lander project: Connecting Ridge (CR1, eight image pairs), Shackleton rim (SR12, seven pairs) and Malapert (MP1, eight pairs) [36]. LROC added a 3.5 m DTM of Connecting Ridge in April 2024 (LOLA RMS 1.06 m) [37]. The others are Malapert 01 to 03 and Nobile 01 to 04 at 3 to 4 m [35]. Stereo needs off-nadir slews (at most four per day) and pairs with similar lighting [21]. One 2012 study found four usable pairs for a Shackleton rim site, with incidence near 88.6° [20]. NASA (5 m, 13 regions) and JAXA (1 m, six sites) both built their South Pole products with SfS in the Ames Stereo Pipeline, controlled to LOLA [10][12][13].
  3. Kaguya and LRO wide-area products add nothing at the pole. SLDEM2015 stops at ±60° [18]. WAC GLD100 stops at ±79° and is filled with LOLA beyond [19]. In SLDEM2013, Kaguya TC stereo leaves gaps at high latitude that JAXA filled with MI and LOLA data [17]. LOLA polar DEMs cover 80 to 90°S at 20 m/pixel and 83 to 90°S at 10 m/pixel [7].
  4. Thermal data are 240 m/pixel or coarser, and Diviner rock abundance does not reach the pole. The Polar Cumulative Product (PCP) gives temperatures at 240 m for 80 to 90°S [27]. The Polar Resource Product (PRP) gives thermal-model fits to first-year data (temperatures, ice depth) on a mesh of 2,880,000 triangles to 80°S [27]; that is about 500 m per cell (estimate from the mesh size). Archived rock-abundance maps cover ±60° (32 pixels per degree) and 70°S to 70°N (128 pixels per degree) [28][27].
  5. Terms of use: NASA sources allow commercial reuse; ISRO and ESA archive data need permission; JAXA terms conflict. PDS data are public domain [1]. LROC products are public domain only when taken from the PDS archive [2]. SPICE needs no licence [4]. The NASA and JAXA SfS products on Zenodo are CC BY 4.0 [11][13]. Chandrayaan-2 data are for non-profit scientific use [29]. ESA archive data are CC BY-NC and need ESA authorisation for commercial use [30]. JAXA Kaguya terms conflict between pages [14][15][16].
  6. Measured data to validate derived layers exist. LROC publishes controlled 1 m/pixel NAC mosaics of Artemis candidate regions and an 84 to 90°S mosaic built from 18,323 images in bins of sub-solar longitude [23][24]. NASA publishes 18.6-year average illumination and Earth-visibility maps at 60 to 240 m [9]. At the candidate sites the Zenodo archive of the NASA SfS DEMs is a better source than the mosaics: it holds the input NAC images orthorectified one by one to the 5 m grid, with dates and the adjusted camera for each image, for example 322 images at Connecting Ridge [11].
  7. Permanently shadowed regions (PSRs) are covered by LOLA and ShadowCam only. ShadowCam images are 1.7 m/pixel and its DTMs are controlled to LOLA; sunlit terrain saturates, and DTMs carry artefacts of 0.5 to 1 m [25][26].
  8. LRO still acquires data. LROC released images taken up to 15 April 2026 on 2 July 2026 [3]. Near the pole this adds little: 16 of the 403 NAC images that cover the Connecting Ridge reference point are later than 2019 (count by the research agent in B2-site-data-coverage.md, not a published figure) [35]. Chang'e-7 is delayed to 2027 (news) [33], so no new South Pole data from it is expected before a Type A start (judgement).

3. Evidence table

Licence quotes: "Data sets archived in the PDS are in the public domain" [1]; LROC PDS products are "in the public domain" [2]; SPICE: "No fees or licensing are required" [4]; ISAS: "open data can be used free of charge, either for commercial or non-commercial purposes" [14]; ISRO: "it should not be used for any commercial purposes" [29].

Data set Instrument, mission Archive Licence, commercial use Resolution South Pole coverage Known limitations
LOLA polar DEMs [7][8] LOLA, LRO PDS Geosciences, PGDA Public domain [1] 5 m mosaic; 10 m; 20 m reference Mosaic file name 87S; 83°S and 80°S to pole Effective resolution 20 m poleward of 84°S, 56 m in outer test tile; 20 m fill 15 to 75%
Site LOLA DEMs [5][6] LOLA, LRO PGDA No licence text on page; citation requested 5 m; uncertainty maps; 100 clones More than 25 named sites About 90% of pixels interpolated
SfS DEMs [10][11] NAC and LOLA, LRO PGDA, Zenodo CC BY 4.0 5 m 13 Artemis regions (2022), over 4,500 km² Error figures not on page; paper not opened
LUPEX DTMs (archive label; the paper mentions LUPEX only as an example of mission interest [38]) [12][13] NAC, LRO; SfS JLPEDA, Zenodo CC BY 4.0 1 m; orthomosaic; uncertainty maps Six sites, named by ESA Lunar Lander RoI: CR1 (Connecting Ridge), GR1 and GR2 (de Gerlache Rim), LP1 (Leibnitz beta Plateau, on Mons Mouton), MP1 and MP2 (Malapert Peak) [13][38][39] NoData in shadow; six NAC left-right pairs (12 images) per site [38]; the authors call the uncertainty maps "a sensitivity diagnostic, not a posterior standard deviation" [38]
NAC images [2][3] LROC NAC, LRO LROC PDS node Public domain from PDS archive; other LROC web content needs permission 1.2 to 1.7 m in the polar listings read [23] Thousands of images poleward of 84°S [23] Incidence 84 to 90°; shadows; stereo rare
NAC stereo DTMs [21][22] LROC NAC, LRO LROC PDS node Public domain 2 m (DLR: CR1 with eight pairs, 5 x 5 km; also SR12, MP1) [36]; 3.5 m (LROC, 2024) [37]; 3 to 4 m (LROC, Malapert and Nobile) [35]; 4 m (USGS) 11 DTMs poleward of 83.4°S (count from an ODE query, not a published figure) [35]: Connecting Ridge, Shackleton rim, Malapert, Nobile; USGS near 89°S 210°E USGS DEM minus LOLA: standard deviation 5 m
NAC controlled mosaics [23][24] LROC NAC, LRO LROC PDS node Public domain 1 m Artemis regions; 84 to 90°S Absolute position 5 to 20 m; control network to 85°S
ShadowCam [25][26] ShadowCam, KPLO PDS4 bundle; ODE PDS; no terms on node page 1.7 m images; DTM scale per product PSRs; release of December 2025 covers to December 2024 Artefacts; tool support only in ASP 3.7.0 builds
Diviner PCP, PRP [27] Diviner, LRO PDS Geosciences Public domain PCP 240 m; PRP about 500 m (estimate) 80°S to pole PRP is a model fit on a Kaguya altimeter mesh
Diviner rock abundance [27][28] Diviner, LRO PDS Geosciences Public domain 32 and 128 pixels per degree None Stops at 60° or 70°
SLDEM2013 [17] TC, MI, Kaguya; LOLA DARTS Conflicting pages [14][15][16] 10 m source images Tiles to 90°S Polar gaps filled with MI and LOLA; offsets 10 m horizontal, 5 m vertical
SLDEM2015; GLD100 [18][19] LOLA and TC; LROC WAC PDS, USGS Public domain 59 m; 100 m None (±60°; ±79°) —
Illumination, Earth visibility [9] LOLA, LRO PGDA, PDS Public domain 60, 120, 240 m 85°S, 75°S, 65°S to pole 18.6-year averages, not time series
SPICE kernels [4] NAIF NAIF, PDS No licence; commercial products allowed; unmodified kernels redistributable — — Redistribution of the bare Toolkit needs NAIF clearance
OHRC, TMC-2 [29] Chandrayaan-2 ISSDC PRADAN, login Non-commercial; ISRO copyright About 0.3 m; 5 m Not checked Excluded from a commercial site package
ESA archives [30] For example SMART-1 AMIE PSA CC BY-NC 3.0 IGO; authorisation for commercial use Not checked Not checked —

Not confirmed: KPLO LUTI terms (KARI page blocked); Chang'e-2 20 m DEM terms (product named in [13]); hydrogen and radar data (LEND, Mini-RF, LAMP), listed by a NASA workshop as low resolution or ambiguous [34].

Site view (judgement from product counts).

4. What this means for the Type A scope

  1. Supported at proof-of-concept level: terrain at 5 m with per-cell uncertainty; slope; illumination and Earth visibility. The 100 clones give a route to confidence for derived layers, and NASA showed that height uncertainty changes predicted illumination [6]. Check derived illumination against the per-image orthorectified NAC images in the SfS archive [11], NAC mosaics [23][24] and NASA maps [9].
  2. Supported in sunlit areas only: 1 m terrain from SfS, reused from [11][13] or reproduced. Inside PSRs only LOLA and ShadowCam apply (judgement).
  3. Ruled out from the archives checked: NAC stereo as the main terrain method, Kaguya regional context, a Diviner rock-abundance layer, thermal analysis finer than 240 m, and Chandrayaan-2 or ESA archive data in a commercial site package without permission.
  4. Positioning: under the glossary.md definitions, measured terrain at 5 m would be about 10% of cells; interpolated and SfS cells would be inferred. The count maps already record this [5]. The four data classes describe a real property of the best data (judgement).
  5. Site: Connecting Ridge suits a validation-centred proof of concept and has ESA heritage. A NASA-list site gives a stronger link to current mission planning (judgement).

5. Ready-to-paste sentences

Re-check each against its source before use. Define acronyms again in the section where a sentence is used.

  1. The Planetary Data System (PDS) of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) states that its archived data sets are in the public domain [1].
  2. NASA publishes Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter (LOLA) elevation models of South Pole sites at 5 m per pixel, with height and slope uncertainty maps [5][6].
  3. Near the South Pole, about 10% of the pixels of a 5 m LOLA elevation model contain a measurement; NASA interpolates the other pixels [6].
  4. The Diviner Polar Cumulative Product gives bolometric brightness temperatures at 240 m per pixel for latitudes from 80°S to the pole [27].
  5. The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) publishes 1 m terrain models of six South Pole sites under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence [12][13].

6. Open risks and unknowns

Contradictions with CLAUDE.md or the RFI draft:

  1. Baseline step 1 names Kaguya SLDEM2013 and LRO wide-area products for regional context. At the pole these stop short or are LOLA-filled [17][18][19]. LOLA polar DEMs do this job [7].
  2. Baseline step 2 names NAC stereo at about 0.5 m/pixel. Published South Pole terrain is 1 to 5 m and SfS-based [10][12]. ASP documents SfS as experimental [25]. This confirms risk 2 in A-competitors.md.
  3. Baseline step 6 lists rock abundance. No archived Diviner product covers the pole [27][28]. The ice-depth layer is a model output on a mesh of about 500 m (estimate), not a measurement [27].
  4. The RFI draft treats terrain from mission products as measured. Most 5 m LOLA cells are interpolated [6]; the class rule must say where they belong.

Unknowns:

Decisions for Ivaylo: (a) drop Kaguya from the Type A baseline, or ask JAXA in writing; (b) reuse published DTMs as inputs, or produce SfS terrain in the activity; (c) the class of interpolated cells, SfS cells and model products such as PRP; (d) the site; (e) confirm at which latitude the existing stereo tests were run.

7. Suggested follow-up topics

  1. B2: NAC stereo pairs and SfS image sets at two or three shortlisted sites. Decides the 1 m terrain method and its effort (1.4.4, 1.5).
  2. Written licence position from JAXA (Kaguya) and NASA GSFC (PGDA), and what evidence of compatibility ESA accepts. Needed for 1.4.4 and the compliance matrix.
  3. ShadowCam and LOLA inside PSRs at the chosen site: what can be checked against measured data. Decides whether PSR terrain is in scope (1.2, 1.5).

8. Sources

Accessed 13 November 2026.

  1. PDS Geosciences Node, FAQ: https://pds-geosciences.wustl.edu/faq.html
  2. LROC, terms of use: https://lroc.im-ldi.com/about/terms
  3. LROC, PDS release 67A (extract): https://lroc.im-ldi.com/news
  4. NAIF, SPICE rules: https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/naif/rules.html
  5. NASA PGDA, site LOLA DEMs: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/78 ; home page: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/
  6. Barker et al. 2021 (extracts): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205009660 ; https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20210020639/downloads/leag2021_MikeBarker_v01_STI.pdf
  7. Barker et al. 2023, manuscript: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20230014419/downloads/BarkernewviewSTIupdated.pdf
  8. NASA PGDA, 5 m mosaic (extract): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/81
  9. NASA PGDA, polar illumination (extract): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/69
  10. NASA PGDA, SfS DEMs: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/104
  11. Bertone et al. 2025, Zenodo: https://zenodo.org/records/17954508
  12. JAXA JLPEDA, LUPEX DTMs: https://jlpeda.jaxa.jp/en/product/archive/detail_14/
  13. Hemmi and Inoue 2025, Zenodo: https://zenodo.org/records/17153447 ; figure captions of Hemmi et al. 2025 (extracts): https://www.astroexplorer.org/details/psjae10a4f2 ; https://www.astroexplorer.org/details/psjae10a4f5
  14. ISAS Data Policy: https://www.isas.jaxa.jp/en/researchers/data-policy/
  15. DARTS, Kaguya FAQ: https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/missions/kaguya/faq.html
  16. JAXA tool pages (extracts): https://kadias.selene.darts.isas.jaxa.jp/index_e.html ; https://vp.darts.isas.jaxa.jp/index_en.html ; https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/planet/pdap/selene (opened directly: no terms shown)
  17. Sato, Kaguya TC, 2 March 2021 (extract): https://lsic.jhuapl.edu/uploadedDocs/presentations/763-1.07_Sato_TC_20210302_novoice.pdf ; DARTS, SLDEM2013 (extract): https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/en/datasets/sln-l-tc-5-sldem2013-v1.0
  18. USGS, SLDEM2015 (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/search/map/moon_lro_lola_selene_kaguya_tc_dem_merge_60n60s_59m
  19. LROC, WAC GLD100 (extract): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/WAC_GLD100
  20. ISPRS Archives 2012, Shackleton rim DTM (extract): https://goobi.tib.eu/viewer/fulltext/1663818983/489
  21. Gläser et al., Connecting Ridge (extract): https://core.ac.uk/download/18461994.pdf ; LROC DTM page: https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/dtm_detail/181
  22. Rosiek et al. 2013 (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/ckan/dataset/a0bf8e37-6c28-48e1-a381-ee2b91f7f613/resource/32d36308-9977-4379-ab8c-05f8d587b698/download/lpsc_44_march_2013_abstract_2583.pdf
  23. LROC NAC mosaics (extracts): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_MALAPERTLO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_NOBILE02LO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_MOUTNPLTLO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_SHKLTNPKLO2
  24. LROC South Pole controlled mosaic (extract): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_POLE_SOUTH_CM_245
  25. Ames Stereo Pipeline documentation (extracts): https://stereopipeline.readthedocs.io/en/latest/sfs_usage.html ; https://stereopipeline.readthedocs.io/en/stable/examples/shadowcam.html
  26. ShadowCam: DTM description: https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/Moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/Korea%20Pathfinder%20Lunar%20Orbiter%20(KPLO)/SHADOWCAM/DTM.htm ; release note (extract): https://shadowcam.im-ldi.com/news/1467 ; archive: https://pds.shadowcam.im-ldi.com/
  27. ODE, Diviner PRP, PCP and GHRM (extracts): https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/PRP.htm ; https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/PCP.htm ; https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/Lunar%20Reconnaissance%20Orbiter%20(LRO)/DIVINER/GHRM.htm
  28. ODE, Diviner GDR level 3: https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/GDR_L3.htm
  29. ISSDC PRADAN, Chandrayaan-2 disclaimer: https://pradan.issdc.gov.in/ch2/disclaimer.xhtml ; ISRO data release (extract): https://www.isro.gov.in/CHANDRAAYAN.html ; USGS (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/docs/concepts/missions/chandrayaan2
  30. ESA, archive terms and conditions: https://cosmos.esa.int/web/esdc/terms-and-conditions
  31. NASA, Artemis III regions (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250011660
  32. ESA, Argonaut (extract): https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Exploration/Argonaut
  33. Scientific American, news, 24 August 2026 (extract): https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinas-change-7-moonshot-will-seek-water-ice-at-the-lunar-south-pole/
  34. NASA SSERVI workshop report (extract): https://sservi.nasa.gov/lssw/downloads/Workshop-Report_LSSW-Virtual-Session-Six--Foundational-Data-Products.pdf
  35. PDS Geosciences Node, Orbital Data Explorer REST interface (data; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2-site-data-coverage.md source 1): https://oderest.rsl.wustl.edu/live2/?query=iipy&odemetadb=moon&output=JSON
  36. LROC PDS archive, readme files of the DLR stereo DTMs (full text; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 9): https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_CR1/NAC_DTM_ESALL_CR1_README.TXT ; https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_SR12/NAC_DTM_ESALL_SR12_README.TXT ; https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_MP1/NAC_DTM_ESALL_MP1_README.TXT
  37. LROC, "Shackleton - de Gerlache Connecting Ridge DTM", SHACKRDGE02 (page summary; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 10): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_DTM_SHACKRDGE02
  38. Hemmi et al. 2025, Planetary Science Journal (page summary; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 7): https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/PSJ/ae10a4
  39. De Rosa et al. 2012, ESA Lunar Lander site characterisation (full text; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 12): https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.5587