Topic B — Data sets: findings
13 November 2026; all sources opened that day. Bracketed numbers
refer to section 8. "(extract)" in section 8 marks a source read as a
search extract of the page, not the full page. "Judgement" marks an
assessment, not a sourced fact. "Not found" means searched and not
found. Compiled with AI (Claude); sources not yet re-checked by a
person. Corrected on 15 November 2026 from
B2-site-data-coverage.md, with AI (Claude); the corrections
are not yet re-checked by a person.
1. Feeds
1.2 Requirements; 1.4.4 Implementation aspects; 1.5 Technical Problem Areas and Risks; 1.9 Facilities.
2. Key findings
- LOLA is the terrain backbone at the South Pole, and most of it is interpolated. NASA publishes 5 m/pixel LOLA DEMs with count, height-uncertainty and slope-uncertainty maps and 100 statistical clones for more than 25 named sites, plus a 5 m mosaic around the pole [5][8]. At 5 m about 10% of pixels hold a LOLA return; the rest are interpolated [6]. Typical RMS uncertainty: 0.3 to 0.5 m in height, 1.5 to 2.5° in slope [6].
- NAC stereo is not the main terrain method at the pole;
shape-from-shading (SfS) is the method in use. The PDS holds 11
NAC stereo DTMs poleward of 83.4°S (count from a PDS Orbital Data
Explorer query in
B2-site-data-coverage.md, not a published figure) [35]. DLR made three at 2 m for the ESA Lunar Lander project: Connecting Ridge (CR1, eight image pairs), Shackleton rim (SR12, seven pairs) and Malapert (MP1, eight pairs) [36]. LROC added a 3.5 m DTM of Connecting Ridge in April 2024 (LOLA RMS 1.06 m) [37]. The others are Malapert 01 to 03 and Nobile 01 to 04 at 3 to 4 m [35]. Stereo needs off-nadir slews (at most four per day) and pairs with similar lighting [21]. One 2012 study found four usable pairs for a Shackleton rim site, with incidence near 88.6° [20]. NASA (5 m, 13 regions) and JAXA (1 m, six sites) both built their South Pole products with SfS in the Ames Stereo Pipeline, controlled to LOLA [10][12][13]. - Kaguya and LRO wide-area products add nothing at the pole. SLDEM2015 stops at ±60° [18]. WAC GLD100 stops at ±79° and is filled with LOLA beyond [19]. In SLDEM2013, Kaguya TC stereo leaves gaps at high latitude that JAXA filled with MI and LOLA data [17]. LOLA polar DEMs cover 80 to 90°S at 20 m/pixel and 83 to 90°S at 10 m/pixel [7].
- Thermal data are 240 m/pixel or coarser, and Diviner rock abundance does not reach the pole. The Polar Cumulative Product (PCP) gives temperatures at 240 m for 80 to 90°S [27]. The Polar Resource Product (PRP) gives thermal-model fits to first-year data (temperatures, ice depth) on a mesh of 2,880,000 triangles to 80°S [27]; that is about 500 m per cell (estimate from the mesh size). Archived rock-abundance maps cover ±60° (32 pixels per degree) and 70°S to 70°N (128 pixels per degree) [28][27].
- Terms of use: NASA sources allow commercial reuse; ISRO and ESA archive data need permission; JAXA terms conflict. PDS data are public domain [1]. LROC products are public domain only when taken from the PDS archive [2]. SPICE needs no licence [4]. The NASA and JAXA SfS products on Zenodo are CC BY 4.0 [11][13]. Chandrayaan-2 data are for non-profit scientific use [29]. ESA archive data are CC BY-NC and need ESA authorisation for commercial use [30]. JAXA Kaguya terms conflict between pages [14][15][16].
- Measured data to validate derived layers exist. LROC publishes controlled 1 m/pixel NAC mosaics of Artemis candidate regions and an 84 to 90°S mosaic built from 18,323 images in bins of sub-solar longitude [23][24]. NASA publishes 18.6-year average illumination and Earth-visibility maps at 60 to 240 m [9]. At the candidate sites the Zenodo archive of the NASA SfS DEMs is a better source than the mosaics: it holds the input NAC images orthorectified one by one to the 5 m grid, with dates and the adjusted camera for each image, for example 322 images at Connecting Ridge [11].
- Permanently shadowed regions (PSRs) are covered by LOLA and ShadowCam only. ShadowCam images are 1.7 m/pixel and its DTMs are controlled to LOLA; sunlit terrain saturates, and DTMs carry artefacts of 0.5 to 1 m [25][26].
- LRO still acquires data. LROC released images taken
up to 15 April 2026 on 2 July 2026 [3]. Near the pole this adds
little: 16 of the 403 NAC images that cover the Connecting Ridge
reference point are later than 2019 (count by the research agent in
B2-site-data-coverage.md, not a published figure) [35]. Chang'e-7 is delayed to 2027 (news) [33], so no new South Pole data from it is expected before a Type A start (judgement).
3. Evidence table
Licence quotes: "Data sets archived in the PDS are in the public domain" [1]; LROC PDS products are "in the public domain" [2]; SPICE: "No fees or licensing are required" [4]; ISAS: "open data can be used free of charge, either for commercial or non-commercial purposes" [14]; ISRO: "it should not be used for any commercial purposes" [29].
| Data set | Instrument, mission | Archive | Licence, commercial use | Resolution | South Pole coverage | Known limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LOLA polar DEMs [7][8] | LOLA, LRO | PDS Geosciences, PGDA | Public domain [1] | 5 m mosaic; 10 m; 20 m reference | Mosaic file name 87S; 83°S and 80°S to pole | Effective resolution 20 m poleward of 84°S, 56 m in outer test tile; 20 m fill 15 to 75% |
| Site LOLA DEMs [5][6] | LOLA, LRO | PGDA | No licence text on page; citation requested | 5 m; uncertainty maps; 100 clones | More than 25 named sites | About 90% of pixels interpolated |
| SfS DEMs [10][11] | NAC and LOLA, LRO | PGDA, Zenodo | CC BY 4.0 | 5 m | 13 Artemis regions (2022), over 4,500 km² | Error figures not on page; paper not opened |
| LUPEX DTMs (archive label; the paper mentions LUPEX only as an example of mission interest [38]) [12][13] | NAC, LRO; SfS | JLPEDA, Zenodo | CC BY 4.0 | 1 m; orthomosaic; uncertainty maps | Six sites, named by ESA Lunar Lander RoI: CR1 (Connecting Ridge), GR1 and GR2 (de Gerlache Rim), LP1 (Leibnitz beta Plateau, on Mons Mouton), MP1 and MP2 (Malapert Peak) [13][38][39] | NoData in shadow; six NAC left-right pairs (12 images) per site [38]; the authors call the uncertainty maps "a sensitivity diagnostic, not a posterior standard deviation" [38] |
| NAC images [2][3] | LROC NAC, LRO | LROC PDS node | Public domain from PDS archive; other LROC web content needs permission | 1.2 to 1.7 m in the polar listings read [23] | Thousands of images poleward of 84°S [23] | Incidence 84 to 90°; shadows; stereo rare |
| NAC stereo DTMs [21][22] | LROC NAC, LRO | LROC PDS node | Public domain | 2 m (DLR: CR1 with eight pairs, 5 x 5 km; also SR12, MP1) [36]; 3.5 m (LROC, 2024) [37]; 3 to 4 m (LROC, Malapert and Nobile) [35]; 4 m (USGS) | 11 DTMs poleward of 83.4°S (count from an ODE query, not a published figure) [35]: Connecting Ridge, Shackleton rim, Malapert, Nobile; USGS near 89°S 210°E | USGS DEM minus LOLA: standard deviation 5 m |
| NAC controlled mosaics [23][24] | LROC NAC, LRO | LROC PDS node | Public domain | 1 m | Artemis regions; 84 to 90°S | Absolute position 5 to 20 m; control network to 85°S |
| ShadowCam [25][26] | ShadowCam, KPLO | PDS4 bundle; ODE | PDS; no terms on node page | 1.7 m images; DTM scale per product | PSRs; release of December 2025 covers to December 2024 | Artefacts; tool support only in ASP 3.7.0 builds |
| Diviner PCP, PRP [27] | Diviner, LRO | PDS Geosciences | Public domain | PCP 240 m; PRP about 500 m (estimate) | 80°S to pole | PRP is a model fit on a Kaguya altimeter mesh |
| Diviner rock abundance [27][28] | Diviner, LRO | PDS Geosciences | Public domain | 32 and 128 pixels per degree | None | Stops at 60° or 70° |
| SLDEM2013 [17] | TC, MI, Kaguya; LOLA | DARTS | Conflicting pages [14][15][16] | 10 m source images | Tiles to 90°S | Polar gaps filled with MI and LOLA; offsets 10 m horizontal, 5 m vertical |
| SLDEM2015; GLD100 [18][19] | LOLA and TC; LROC WAC | PDS, USGS | Public domain | 59 m; 100 m | None (±60°; ±79°) | — |
| Illumination, Earth visibility [9] | LOLA, LRO | PGDA, PDS | Public domain | 60, 120, 240 m | 85°S, 75°S, 65°S to pole | 18.6-year averages, not time series |
| SPICE kernels [4] | NAIF | NAIF, PDS | No licence; commercial products allowed; unmodified kernels redistributable | — | — | Redistribution of the bare Toolkit needs NAIF clearance |
| OHRC, TMC-2 [29] | Chandrayaan-2 | ISSDC PRADAN, login | Non-commercial; ISRO copyright | About 0.3 m; 5 m | Not checked | Excluded from a commercial site package |
| ESA archives [30] | For example SMART-1 AMIE | PSA | CC BY-NC 3.0 IGO; authorisation for commercial use | Not checked | Not checked | — |
Not confirmed: KPLO LUTI terms (KARI page blocked); Chang'e-2 20 m DEM terms (product named in [13]); hydrogen and radar data (LEND, Mini-RF, LAMP), listed by a NASA workshop as low resolution or ambiguous [34].
Site view (judgement from product counts).
- Connecting Ridge has the most terrain products, six: site LOLA DEM,
SfS at 5 m, JAXA 1 m DTM with uncertainty, DLR stereo DTM, USGS DEM,
LROC 3.5 m stereo DTM [5][11][13][21][22][37].
They are not independent: the NASA SfS, JAXA SfS and stereo DTMs are all
tied to LOLA heights, and the two SfS products are computed from NAC
images [10][36][38].
The USGS DEM was not re-opened in
B2-site-data-coverage.md. ESA chose it as a Lunar Lander candidate site (89.4649°S, 222.1027°E) [21]. It is not in the nine NASA regions of October 2024 [31]. - Malapert Massif, Nobile Rim 1 and 2 and Haworth are in the nine NASA regions and have site LOLA DEMs and SfS DEMs [31][5][11]. De Gerlache Rim 2 is in the nine and has an SfS DEM [11]. NAC mosaics use 184 images at Malapert Massif and 103 at Nobile Rim 2 [23]. Mons Mouton Plateau has a 159-image mosaic [23].
- Peak near Shackleton has a LOLA DEM, an SfS DEM and a 75-image mosaic [5][11][23]; the reported Chang'e-7 target is the Shackleton rim (news) [33].
- Peak near Cabeus B and Slater Plain are in the nine regions [31]; no site DEM was found in the lists read [5][11].
- ESA Argonaut Mission 1 targets the south polar region by end 2030; site not stated [32]. Thermal coverage is the same at every site: 240 m at best.
4. What this means for the Type A scope
- Supported at proof-of-concept level: terrain at 5 m with per-cell uncertainty; slope; illumination and Earth visibility. The 100 clones give a route to confidence for derived layers, and NASA showed that height uncertainty changes predicted illumination [6]. Check derived illumination against the per-image orthorectified NAC images in the SfS archive [11], NAC mosaics [23][24] and NASA maps [9].
- Supported in sunlit areas only: 1 m terrain from SfS, reused from [11][13] or reproduced. Inside PSRs only LOLA and ShadowCam apply (judgement).
- Ruled out from the archives checked: NAC stereo as the main terrain method, Kaguya regional context, a Diviner rock-abundance layer, thermal analysis finer than 240 m, and Chandrayaan-2 or ESA archive data in a commercial site package without permission.
- Positioning: under the
glossary.mddefinitions, measured terrain at 5 m would be about 10% of cells; interpolated and SfS cells would be inferred. The count maps already record this [5]. The four data classes describe a real property of the best data (judgement). - Site: Connecting Ridge suits a validation-centred proof of concept and has ESA heritage. A NASA-list site gives a stronger link to current mission planning (judgement).
5. Ready-to-paste sentences
Re-check each against its source before use. Define acronyms again in the section where a sentence is used.
- The Planetary Data System (PDS) of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) states that its archived data sets are in the public domain [1].
- NASA publishes Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter (LOLA) elevation models of South Pole sites at 5 m per pixel, with height and slope uncertainty maps [5][6].
- Near the South Pole, about 10% of the pixels of a 5 m LOLA elevation model contain a measurement; NASA interpolates the other pixels [6].
- The Diviner Polar Cumulative Product gives bolometric brightness temperatures at 240 m per pixel for latitudes from 80°S to the pole [27].
- The Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) publishes 1 m terrain models of six South Pole sites under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 licence [12][13].
6. Open risks and unknowns
Contradictions with CLAUDE.md or the RFI draft:
- Baseline step 1 names Kaguya SLDEM2013 and LRO wide-area products for regional context. At the pole these stop short or are LOLA-filled [17][18][19]. LOLA polar DEMs do this job [7].
- Baseline step 2 names NAC stereo at about 0.5 m/pixel. Published
South Pole terrain is 1 to 5 m and SfS-based [10][12].
ASP documents SfS as experimental [25].
This confirms risk 2 in
A-competitors.md. - Baseline step 6 lists rock abundance. No archived Diviner product covers the pole [27][28]. The ice-depth layer is a model output on a mesh of about 500 m (estimate), not a measurement [27].
- The RFI draft treats terrain from mission products as measured. Most 5 m LOLA cells are interpolated [6]; the class rule must say where they belong.
Unknowns:
- JAXA terms. The ISAS policy and the Kaguya FAQ allow commercial use without procedure [14][15]. KADIAS, Virtual Planet and an indexed SELENE archive page require prior permission [16]. Which governs: not found.
- PGDA pages carry no licence text [5]. The Zenodo copy of the SfS DEMs is CC BY 4.0 [11]; the site LOLA DEMs have no such copy (not found).
- Stereo pairs and SfS-suitable images per candidate site: not counted in this chat.
- Not opened (publisher blocked): the SfS paper and the JAXA paper.
Their error figures are missing here. The names of the six JAXA sites
are now in the LUPEX DTMs row, from
B2-site-data-coverage.mdfinding 6. - ShadowCam coverage per site; SMART-1 coverage; LRO end date: not found.
- News sources, nothing better found: [33].
Decisions for Ivaylo: (a) drop Kaguya from the Type A baseline, or ask JAXA in writing; (b) reuse published DTMs as inputs, or produce SfS terrain in the activity; (c) the class of interpolated cells, SfS cells and model products such as PRP; (d) the site; (e) confirm at which latitude the existing stereo tests were run.
7. Suggested follow-up topics
- B2: NAC stereo pairs and SfS image sets at two or three shortlisted sites. Decides the 1 m terrain method and its effort (1.4.4, 1.5).
- Written licence position from JAXA (Kaguya) and NASA GSFC (PGDA), and what evidence of compatibility ESA accepts. Needed for 1.4.4 and the compliance matrix.
- ShadowCam and LOLA inside PSRs at the chosen site: what can be checked against measured data. Decides whether PSR terrain is in scope (1.2, 1.5).
8. Sources
Accessed 13 November 2026.
- PDS Geosciences Node, FAQ: https://pds-geosciences.wustl.edu/faq.html
- LROC, terms of use: https://lroc.im-ldi.com/about/terms
- LROC, PDS release 67A (extract): https://lroc.im-ldi.com/news
- NAIF, SPICE rules: https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/naif/rules.html
- NASA PGDA, site LOLA DEMs: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/78 ; home page: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/
- Barker et al. 2021 (extracts): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205009660 ; https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20210020639/downloads/leag2021_MikeBarker_v01_STI.pdf
- Barker et al. 2023, manuscript: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20230014419/downloads/BarkernewviewSTIupdated.pdf
- NASA PGDA, 5 m mosaic (extract): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/81
- NASA PGDA, polar illumination (extract): https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/69
- NASA PGDA, SfS DEMs: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/104
- Bertone et al. 2025, Zenodo: https://zenodo.org/records/17954508
- JAXA JLPEDA, LUPEX DTMs: https://jlpeda.jaxa.jp/en/product/archive/detail_14/
- Hemmi and Inoue 2025, Zenodo: https://zenodo.org/records/17153447 ; figure captions of Hemmi et al. 2025 (extracts): https://www.astroexplorer.org/details/psjae10a4f2 ; https://www.astroexplorer.org/details/psjae10a4f5
- ISAS Data Policy: https://www.isas.jaxa.jp/en/researchers/data-policy/
- DARTS, Kaguya FAQ: https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/missions/kaguya/faq.html
- JAXA tool pages (extracts): https://kadias.selene.darts.isas.jaxa.jp/index_e.html ; https://vp.darts.isas.jaxa.jp/index_en.html ; https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/planet/pdap/selene (opened directly: no terms shown)
- Sato, Kaguya TC, 2 March 2021 (extract): https://lsic.jhuapl.edu/uploadedDocs/presentations/763-1.07_Sato_TC_20210302_novoice.pdf ; DARTS, SLDEM2013 (extract): https://darts.isas.jaxa.jp/en/datasets/sln-l-tc-5-sldem2013-v1.0
- USGS, SLDEM2015 (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/search/map/moon_lro_lola_selene_kaguya_tc_dem_merge_60n60s_59m
- LROC, WAC GLD100 (extract): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/WAC_GLD100
- ISPRS Archives 2012, Shackleton rim DTM (extract): https://goobi.tib.eu/viewer/fulltext/1663818983/489
- Gläser et al., Connecting Ridge (extract): https://core.ac.uk/download/18461994.pdf ; LROC DTM page: https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/dtm_detail/181
- Rosiek et al. 2013 (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/ckan/dataset/a0bf8e37-6c28-48e1-a381-ee2b91f7f613/resource/32d36308-9977-4379-ab8c-05f8d587b698/download/lpsc_44_march_2013_abstract_2583.pdf
- LROC NAC mosaics (extracts): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_MALAPERTLO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_NOBILE02LO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_MOUTNPLTLO1 ; https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_ROI_SHKLTNPKLO2
- LROC South Pole controlled mosaic (extract): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_POLE_SOUTH_CM_245
- Ames Stereo Pipeline documentation (extracts): https://stereopipeline.readthedocs.io/en/latest/sfs_usage.html ; https://stereopipeline.readthedocs.io/en/stable/examples/shadowcam.html
- ShadowCam: DTM description: https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/Moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/Korea%20Pathfinder%20Lunar%20Orbiter%20(KPLO)/SHADOWCAM/DTM.htm ; release note (extract): https://shadowcam.im-ldi.com/news/1467 ; archive: https://pds.shadowcam.im-ldi.com/
- ODE, Diviner PRP, PCP and GHRM (extracts): https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/PRP.htm ; https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/PCP.htm ; https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/Lunar%20Reconnaissance%20Orbiter%20(LRO)/DIVINER/GHRM.htm
- ODE, Diviner GDR level 3: https://ode.rsl.wustl.edu/moon/pagehelp/Content/Missions_Instruments/LRO/DIVINER/GDR_L3.htm
- ISSDC PRADAN, Chandrayaan-2 disclaimer: https://pradan.issdc.gov.in/ch2/disclaimer.xhtml ; ISRO data release (extract): https://www.isro.gov.in/CHANDRAAYAN.html ; USGS (extract): https://astrogeology.usgs.gov/docs/concepts/missions/chandrayaan2
- ESA, archive terms and conditions: https://cosmos.esa.int/web/esdc/terms-and-conditions
- NASA, Artemis III regions (extract): https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20250011660
- ESA, Argonaut (extract): https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Exploration/Argonaut
- Scientific American, news, 24 August 2026 (extract): https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinas-change-7-moonshot-will-seek-water-ice-at-the-lunar-south-pole/
- NASA SSERVI workshop report (extract): https://sservi.nasa.gov/lssw/downloads/Workshop-Report_LSSW-Virtual-Session-Six--Foundational-Data-Products.pdf
- PDS Geosciences Node, Orbital Data Explorer REST interface (data;
accessed 15 November 2026, via
B2-site-data-coverage.mdsource 1): https://oderest.rsl.wustl.edu/live2/?query=iipy&odemetadb=moon&output=JSON - LROC PDS archive, readme files of the DLR stereo DTMs (full text; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 9): https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_CR1/NAC_DTM_ESALL_CR1_README.TXT ; https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_SR12/NAC_DTM_ESALL_SR12_README.TXT ; https://pds.lroc.im-ldi.com/data/LRO-L-LROC-5-RDR-V1.0/LROLRC_2001/DATA/SDP/NAC_DTM/ESALL_MP1/NAC_DTM_ESALL_MP1_README.TXT
- LROC, "Shackleton - de Gerlache Connecting Ridge DTM", SHACKRDGE02 (page summary; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 10): https://data.lroc.im-ldi.com/lroc/view_rdr/NAC_DTM_SHACKRDGE02
- Hemmi et al. 2025, Planetary Science Journal (page summary; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 7): https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/PSJ/ae10a4
- De Rosa et al. 2012, ESA Lunar Lander site characterisation (full text; accessed 15 November 2026, via B2 source 12): https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.5587