Topic A — Competitors and prior ESA-funded work: findings
13 November 2026; sources read that day, some as search-engine extracts of the page. Links re-checked in a browser on 14 November 2026: sources 1, 4, 7, 8, 13 and 32 were replaced (section 6). Bracketed numbers refer to section 8. "Judgement" marks an assessment, not a sourced fact. "Not found" means searched and not found. Compiled with AI (Claude); sources not yet re-checked by a person.
Length: about 2,000 words before the source list. This is over the
two-page limit of research-brief.md, because the topic file
asks for an exhaustive list. Sources often say DTM (digital terrain
model); this file uses DEM throughout.
Abbreviations not in glossary.md: OSIP = ESA Open Space
Innovation Platform; PGDA = NASA Planetary Geodesy Data Archive; DLES =
Digital Lunar Exploration Sites; SfS = shape-from-shading; XR, VR =
extended, virtual reality; UE5 = Unreal Engine 5.
1. Feeds
1.4.1 State of the Art; 1.6.1 programmatic compliance (no duplication); 1.6.2 Business Case Summary.
2. Key findings
Details and further products are in the table (section 3).
- CNES is building a "digital twin of the Moon" for South Pole planning: 3D terrain from the LOLA 5 m/pixel DEM, ray-cast illumination maps, slope maps, illuminated rover paths, base siting near Shackleton. The paper refers to ESA's ExPeRT team [5]. Closest European overlap.
- ESA funds a lunar digital-twin activity now. ADTLAS is an ESA OSIP activity led by Fraunhofer FIT, with ESA and industry partners [1][2]. It builds digital models of the lunar environment to extend the ESA-DLR LUNA analogue facility with mixed reality [2]. ESA's activities record gave a start on 3 September 2025, 24 months and EUR 70,000; that record no longer opens in a browser (section 6). ESA's XR Lab also has LUNA-XR and a VR model of the South Pole built from LRO topographic maps [3][4].
- Five ESA projects from a 2023 OSIP campaign cover baseline steps 2, 3 and 7: shape-from-shading (SfS) and deep-learning DEM software; an open-source monocular image-to-topography toolbox; inverse rendering of elevation maps; photorealistic Moon views; Unreal Engine 5 synthetic data. ESA/ESOC presented them in May 2026 [6]. Contractors and status: not found.
- NASA distributes DUST, a South Pole 3D tool with the same core functions: LOLA DEMs, SPICE Sun and Earth positions, slope maps, traverse visualiser, synthetic sub-pixel craters and rocks [17][18].
- South Pole terrain at 1 to 5 m/pixel with uncertainty is published by NASA [21][22] and JAXA [25]; UCL and TU Berlin with DLR publish deep-learning DEMs [26][27].
- Illumination and line-of-sight analysis from DEMs is standard and free: Moon Trek [19], QuickMap [20], NASA's IllumNG [37]. ESA did it in 2012 for its Lunar Lander study and funded LandSAfe [12][11].
- Commercial suppliers exist in the USA: Lunar Station Corp (MoonHacker) [31] and Astrobotic (LunaRay, DEMkit) [30][40]. ispace and SpaceData agreed in March 2025 to build lunar digital twins [32]. A European commercial supplier of South Pole site packages: not found.
- ESA is moving to buy lunar data and acquire new terrain data: RFI "Commercial Lunar Data Products for Exploration Science", published 15 June 2026 [9]; Moonraker lunar lidar: ESA contracted a Pre-Phase A study [7] and selected the mission for Phase A, announced 16 June 2026 [8].
- No reviewed product documents a per-cell split into measured, derived, inferred and synthetic data across all layers. Closest: PGDA error maps [21], JAXA uncertainty maps [25], per-pixel uncertainty in NASA's 2026 super-resolution method [23]. DLES and PANGU add synthetic detail to measured DEMs [18][14]; per-cell tagging: not found. Judgement: absence in the sources checked, not proof.
3. Evidence table
| Name | Organisation, country | What it does | Data sources | Maturity | Availability, licence | Funding | Gap relative to SELIS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ADTLAS [1][2] | Fraunhofer FIT with ESA and partners, DE | Lunar environment models; mixed reality for LUNA | Not stated | Running; Sep 2025 to 2027 per ESA record (section 6) | Not stated | ESA OSIP; EUR 70,000 per ESA record (section 6) | No site analysis or data classes stated |
| LUNA-XR; VR South Pole [3][4] | ESA XR Lab, DE | Digital twin of LUNA hall; VR training terrain | Heightmaps; LRO topographic maps | Shown 2022 to 2026 | Not stated | ESA | Training visuals only |
| Spaceship FR [5] | CNES, FR | 3D terrain, illumination, slope, rover paths, base siting | LOLA 5 m DEM | First mock-up, 2025 | Not stated | CNES | No NAC terrain, Earth visibility or data classes |
| Five 2023 OSIP projects [6] | Not found | DEM software, topography toolbox, rendering, synthetic data | Not found | Presented May 2026 | One open source | ESA OSIP | Components, not a site package |
| Moonraker [7][8] | NUVIEW, DE | Orbital lidar for polar DEMs | New mission | Phase A, 2026 | Not applicable | ESA | Future data source |
| LandSAfe; Lunar Lander study [11][12] | ESA with universities, JHU APL | DEMs; hazard, illumination, temperature maps | NAC, LOLA | 2012; status not found | Not found | ESA | Precedent for steps 2 and 5 |
| PANGU; SurRender [13][14][16] | Univ. of Dundee, UK; Airbus, FR | Camera and lidar image simulation; DEM enhancement | LOLA, NAC, Chang'e-2 DEMs | PANGU v7 | Commercial; proprietary | ESA; Airbus | Navigation testing, no site analysis |
| EXPLORE L-Hex [15] | ACRI-ST consortium, EU | Web app for landing-site characterisation | Orbital data | Ended Dec 2023 | Web | EU Horizon 2020 | No illumination or site package stated |
| MADNet; ELunarDTMNet [26][27] | UCL, UK; TU Berlin, DLR, DE | Deep-learning DEMs, about 1 m | NAC, ShadowCam, LOLA | Published 2024 to 2026 | Papers | Not stated | Terrain only |
| DUST with DLES [17][18] | NASA JSC, US | 3D South Pole; lighting, slope, traverse; synthetic craters | LOLA DEMs | In use | General Public Release | NASA | No data classes stated |
| Moon Trek [19] | NASA JPL, US | Lighting, slope, line of sight, traverse | Mapped mission data | Operational | Free, web | NASA | Portal, not a site package |
| QuickMap [20] | ASU, ACT, US | 2D and 3D map; shadows; visibility | LROC, Diviner, Mini-RF | Operational | Free, web | NASA | As Moon Trek |
| PGDA products [21][22][23] | NASA GSFC, US | 5 m DEMs, error maps, SfS, super-resolution | LOLA, NAC | 2021 to 2026 | Open | NASA | Inputs and references for SELIS |
| LuNaMaps [24] | NASA, US | Navigation maps; synthetic rocks; validation tools | LOLA, NAC | Plan, Aug 2024 | Via PGDA | NASA | Navigation focus |
| LUPEX site DEMs [25] | JAXA, JP | 1 m DEMs, six sites | NAC, LOLA | 2025 | Open | JAXA | Terrain only |
| MoonHacker [31] | Lunar Station Corp, US | Fused site analysis | PDS, LRO | Commercial | Proprietary | Private | Closest commercial competitor; method not public |
| LunaRay, DEMkit [30][40] | Astrobotic, US | Lighting, line-of-sight and solar maps; DEMs | Orbital images, lidar | In use | Proprietary | Private | No data classes stated |
| Lunar digital twin [32] | ispace, SpaceData, JP | Terrain with physics simulation | ispace mission data | Agreement, 2025 | Not stated | Private | Not yet a product |
| Cesium Moon [33][34] | Cesium, US | Global 3D terrain tiles; base for RF modelling | LOLA, WAC, Kaguya | Released Aug 2024 | Account | Private | Base layer only |
| OmniLRS; Lunar Autonomy Challenge [28][29] | Univ. of Luxembourg, Tohoku; NASA, JHU APL | Robotics simulation, synthetic data | Procedural terrain | 2023 to 2025 | Open source; challenge | Public | Not tied to a measured site |
Also seen, physical or construction-focused: ALTEC Lunar Simulation Centre (ASI, due end 2026) [35]; Japanese Stardust construction simulators [36].
Duplication check (judgement). SELIS would duplicate if it proposes: an XR or training environment (ADTLAS, XR Lab); a general Moon digital twin for operations planning on LOLA data (Spaceship FR); new DEM or super-resolution methods (OSIP projects, PGDA, TU Berlin, UCL); a navigation image simulator (PANGU, SurRender). SELIS complements them if it supplies a traceable site package that they can ingest, and reuses their tools and data.
4. What this means for the Type A scope
- Supported: a South Pole site package whose research question is traceability: the four data classes with per-cell provenance and confidence, checked against independent measured data. It is the only element not found elsewhere (judgement).
- Ruled out as novelty claims: DEM generation, illumination and Earth-visibility ray tracing, a real-time 3D South Pole scene, synthetic rocks and craters, "the first lunar digital twin".
- Reuse, do not rebuild: PGDA and JAXA terrain as inputs and validation references; Moon Trek, QuickMap or DUST outputs as cross-checks for derived layers (judgement).
- Position SELIS as a supplier of traceable site data to ADTLAS, the XR Lab and Spaceship FR, and as a user of the OSIP tools and later of Moonraker data.
- The 3D environment (baseline step 7) overlaps most with DUST, Spaceship FR and ADTLAS. Reduce it to a viewer, or drop it (judgement).
5. Ready-to-paste sentences
Re-check each against its source before use. Define acronyms again in the section where a sentence is used.
- The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) distributes DUST, a three-dimensional tool for the lunar South Pole built on Lunar Orbiter Laser Altimeter elevation data [17].
- The European Space Agency (ESA) and Fraunhofer FIT run ADTLAS, an ESA innovation activity that builds digital models of the lunar environment for analogue testing [1][2].
- The Centre National d'Études Spatiales (CNES) is developing a digital twin of the Moon that computes illumination maps and rover paths from altimeter data [5].
- NASA and the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) publish South Pole terrain models at 5 m and 1 m per pixel with uncertainty estimates [21][25].
- Luminous found no existing lunar product that documents a per-cell separation of measured, derived, inferred and synthetic data (review of November 2026; section 3).
6. Open risks and unknowns
Contradictions with CLAUDE.md or the RFI draft:
CLAUDE.mdframes the problem as fragmented data. Moon Trek and QuickMap already co-register LRO, Diviner and other layers and analyse lighting, slope and line of sight [19][20]. Narrow the problem to what those portals do not deliver.- Baseline step 2 relies on NAC stereo. Published South Pole products use SfS or deep learning [22][25][27]; one source puts NAC stereo coverage at 1% of the surface or less [26]. Topic B must test stereo coverage at the chosen site.
- The RFI draft presents the 3D environment and synthetic layer as product features. DUST, PANGU and Spaceship FR already provide both [17][14][5].
- The data-class separation is supported only as "not found elsewhere", which is weaker than "does not exist".
Unknowns:
- OSIP projects: contractors, status, licences not found (activities.esa.int, nebula.esa.int). A University of Tartu framework matches the fifth title; link not confirmed [39].
- Spaceship FR and ADTLAS: output availability and roadmaps not stated; the ESA role in Spaceship FR needs checking.
- One paper says DUST is not public [38]; NASA's catalogue says General Public Release [17]. Access from Bulgaria not tested.
- RFI scope and dates come from news (released 12 June, due 14 September 2026) [10]. Do not present the RFI as ESA interest in SELIS.
- Not covered: ISRO, CNSA, KARI tools (not searched); earlier Bulgarian PECS projects (one search, none found); MoonHacker and LunaRay prices and customers (not found).
- News or press sources, nothing better found: [1], [7], [8], [10], [31] second link, [34].
- Link check, 14 November 2026: three ESA pages no longer open in a browser, although a direct fetch still returned their content that day. The facts below rest on them alone. Do not use them in proposal text until a person has opened the page, for example with an ESA OSIP account (not tested).
- ADTLAS start on 3 September 2025, 24 months, EUR 70,000, contract 4000149521: https://activities.esa.int/node/4142 (403, or ESA OSIP login).
- PANGU under ESA's TRP, TRL 5, closed 2017: https://esa.int/Our_Activities/Space_Engineering_Technology/Shaping_the_Future/Planet_and_Asteroid_Natural_Scene_Generation_Utility_PANGU_Tool_Enhancement (404). Removed from the table.
- Moonraker Pre-Phase A record: https://activities.esa.int/node/3253 (403, or ESA OSIP login). The study is now cited from [7].
Decisions for Ivaylo: (a) keep, reduce or drop the 3D environment; (b) name Spaceship FR, ADTLAS and the OSIP projects in 1.4.1 and 1.6.1 as complemented activities; (c) whether "digital twin" stays the headline term, since ESA and CNES use it for XR and operations tools.
7. Suggested follow-up topics
- The five 2023 OSIP projects: who, what was delivered, which licence. Decides reuse or duplication (1.6.1, work packages).
- Spaceship FR and ADTLAS: outputs, availability, input needs. Decides whether they are named as users (1.6.1, 1.6.2).
- MoonHacker and LunaRay: customers, prices, access for European users. Needed for revenues in 1.6.2.
8. Sources
Accessed 13 November 2026. Sources 1, 4, 7, 8, 13 and 32 were replaced and accessed on 14 November 2026.
- Business Wire, FusionLayer release on ADTLAS, 26 February 2026: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260226842277/en/FusionLayer-the-European-Space-Agency-and-Fraunhofer-FIT-Collaborate-on-ADTLAS-Project-to-Pioneer-Digital-Infrastructure-for-Future-Lunar-Missions
- Fraunhofer FIT, ADTLAS: https://www.fit.fraunhofer.de/adtlas
- ESA, LUNA-XR, 2026: https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2026/05/Extended_reality_at_ESA
- Nilsson et al. 2022 (ESA), VR model of the lunar South Pole: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2203.13941 ; ESA blog, 17 May 2023: https://blogs.esa.int/exploration/?p=2601
- Navarro et al., SpaceOps 2025: https://publications.spaceops.org/2025/download_by_id.php?id=0211
- ESA Lunar Surface Workshop programme: https://atpi.eventsair.com/lunar-surface-workshop/programme
- SFL Missions release on the Moonraker Pre-Phase A study, 10 June 2025: https://sflmissions.com/sfl-missions-inc-included-on-team-awarded-moon-mapping-study-contract-by-european-space-agency-esa/
- NUVIEW press release, 16 June 2026: https://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/nuview-selected-by-esa-in-next-phase-of-lunar-lidar-mission-302799621.html
- ESA, RFI listing: https://explorationscience.esa.int/research-opportunities/request-for-information-commercial-lunar-data-products-for-exploration-science/
- SpaceQ, news: https://spaceq.ca/?p=48534
- Schmidt et al. 2012, LandSAfe: https://isprs-archives.copernicus.org/articles/XXXIX-B4/505/2012/ ; https://orbi.uliege.be/handle/2268/144922
- De Rosa et al. 2012: https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.5587
- STAR-Dundee, PANGU product page: https://www.star-dundee.com/?p=9733
- STAR-Dundee, PANGU v7 datasheet: https://www.star-dundee.com/wp-content/star_uploads/product_resources/datasheets/PANGU-v7-Datasheet.pdf
- EXPLORE: https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2022/EPSC2022-507.html ; https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101004214/reporting
- Airbus, SurRender: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2409.11450
- NASA Software Catalog, DUST: https://software.nasa.gov/software/MSC-27522-1
- NASA, DUST presentation: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20230001371/downloads/DUST_Presentation.pdf
- NASA, Moon Trek: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20220010585
- ACT, QuickMap July 2024: https://www.actgate.com/post/july-2024-quickmap-release
- NASA PGDA: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/78 ; https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/81
- NASA PGDA, SfS: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/104
- NASA PGDA, super-resolution: https://pgda.gsfc.nasa.gov/products/106
- NASA, LuNaMaps plan: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20240012328/downloads/LuNaMaps_TechTransfer.pdf
- JAXA, LUPEX DEMs: https://jlpeda.jaxa.jp/en/product/archive/detail_14/
- Muller et al., EPSC2024: https://meetingorganizer.copernicus.org/EPSC2024/EPSC2024-1170.html
- Chen et al. 2026: https://www.arxiv.org/pdf/2601.09468
- OmniLRS: https://arxiv.org/abs/2309.08997
- Lunar Autonomy Challenge: https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/stmd/student-lunar-autonomy-challenge ; https://arxiv.org/html/2603.17232
- Astrobotic software sheet: https://smd-cms.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/astrobotic-landing-simulation-toolkits.pdf
- Lunar Station: https://www.nasa.gov/technology/tech-transfer-spinoffs/nasa-data-helps-commercial-space-plan-living-off-our-moon/ ; https://satnews.com/2026/08/13/lunar-station-corp-integrates-nasa-datasets-to-model-commercial-surface-infrastructure/
- ispace press release, 7 March 2025: https://www.ispace-inc.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/ispace-and-SpaceData-Agree-to-Collaborate-on-Lunar-Surface-Digital-Twin-Creation-to-Expand-the-Lunar-Market.pdf
- Cesium Moon: https://cesium.com/platform/cesium-ion/content/cesium-moon-terrain ; https://cesium.com/blog/2024/08/06/introducing-cesium-moon-terrain/
- RCR Wireless, news: https://www.rcrwireless.com/20260427/test-measurement/inside-nasas-lunar-network-built-on-synopsys-digital-twins
- ALTEC, SpaceOps 2025: https://publications.spaceops.org/2025/download_by_id.php?id=0507
- MLIT Japan: https://www.mlit.go.jp/en/tec/content/001907890.pdf
- Mazarico et al. 2018: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6398960
- Chrono sensor simulation paper: https://arxiv.org/html/2410.04371v1
- Univ. of Tartu, IAC 2024: https://iafastro.directory/iac/paper/id/90148/abstract-pdf/IAC-24,D4,1,12,x90148.brief.pdf
- Astrobotic, DEMkit and LunaRay: https://seal.ae.gatech.edu/sites/default/files/2022-10/SIW22-22_0.pdf